Stayed at the Rogue's Harbor Inn for my sister's 30th birthday for 2 nights with them and another couple.

The Inn itself is nice and close to Ithaca, without having to deal with the hub-bub of downtown. The road the Inn is situated on is at the intersection of 2 roads, so at times you can hear the sounds of trucks driving through - but the beds provided a comfortable sleep and I must say that while sleeping on the second floor I was not woken by the sounds of trucks at all. Our room was spacious, with a queen sized bed, twin bed and a couch. The beds were definitely comfortable, and the robes they left in the closets for after showers were cozy and comfy. The breakfasts were absolutely amazing- up to the third floor to the common room where we all sat down together and had breakfast. Egg souffles, bacon, rosemary potatoes (which I am still missing), fresh bread and butter from a local farm. The breakfast for both days were hands down awesome.

The inn is definitely interesting with its history, which they have decorated the walls with photos and articles regarding the history. Quirky, and filled with history. A plus is that downstairs on the main floor there is a restaurant to eat at that has pretty good food, as well as their own homemade beer. Convenient to know there is a restaurant downstairs without having to jump in the car and drive down the road.

Overall, our group was pleased with Rogue's Harbor Inn, and are already planning a trip back up. With reasonably priced rooms, good breakfasts, cozy rooms, and a restaurant downstairs, what more could you ask for?

The inn is at the intersection of 2 busy roads--we heard trucks downshifting all night. The decor in our room (#6) was drab and sad. Our beds were made up every day, but no clean towels were given and the floors were not vacuumed. The breakfasts were adequate. The staff was nice, but did not go out of their way to provide good service.

The hotel is actually in South Lansing, about 5 miles north of Ithaca. It is not really near anything else; if you were planning on wandering around you will have to do it by car. The hotel is historically interesting and has been restored modestly, not lavishly. If you are into high-end B&Bs, you'll probably be disappointed; if you're into quirky local establishments, you will be quite comfortable. For the price, it's a good night's sleep. The Rogue's Harbor Brewing Company, which occupies a shed behind the hotel and sells beer at the hotel bar, makes an outstanding amber ale.

We managed to get a room here at a very crowded time in Ithaca NY--just before Cornell's graduation. The hotel has been lovingly restored but still shows its age by the distinctiveness of rooms. Ours was very comfortable with private bath. A breakfast was included. It also has a decent restaurant/bar on the ground floor--a real plus for a place outside of town. Because it was a 19th century hostelry, it is on the intersection of two state roads, so there are no extensive grounds. We had some business in Ithaca, but also were sightseeing in the area. The hotel itself doesn't have business type amenities, but we did not need them there. It was a fine location for sightseeing in the region.