We were traveling to OH and behind schedule because of traffic and various things. It was 12:45 AM and we had 7 hours still to go but needed some rest. Got off the throughway hoping to get 2 rooms at the Comfort Inn but unfortunately they only had 1 room, the Budget Inn was locked up for the night and then there was this. They opened there door and had 2 rooms so for that we were thankful and knowing we were only going to sleep for about 4 hours was OK. The rooms were rundown and a bit scary. We did as little as possible, got up at 5 AM and we were on the road by 6:30. They did have a Dunkin Donuts next door and a gas station so that worked for us. Will not get off the highway at exit 44 any more as it is not worth the chance.

It was my first vacation in several years so friends and I decided to head up to New York. We stayed in several small hotels/motels along the way but this was the best by far. I read the reviews when booking online but after calling the property directly found that there are now new owners to the property and in the last year it has undergone and continues to do so, renovations to both the guest rooms and property. When we arrived we were greeted with a warm smile and a friendly hello. The rooms are inviting and the beds, very comfortable. We all had a great night's sleep and were ready to go in the morning. The price is right and I would definitely recommend it to my fellow travellers.

Just a FYI the Inn in Farmingdale NY is a dump. We stayed one night; the room was run down; the soap despenser was broken and had mildew all over it; there was stains on bedspread; they used simply one flat sheet and not a fitted sheet to bed; ants in the room; stains in bathroom; lock on door was broken. Not a good place; not clean. I will not stay again.

We have stayed here before, and have been satisfied with the rooms. This visit, however, we had a smoking room. It was not well cleaned and many of the amenities (towel bars, chairs, lamps and the like), were missing pieces, gone, or damaged. We were disappointed.