Staying at the Baker House was an almost perfect experience, BUT...there was one big thing that hampered our stay a bit. We stayed in the Fithian Room, which was lovely, except the king bed (2 twins pushed together) was like sleeping on a cement slab. I couldn't believe it. By the time we went home, our backs were broken. I would respectfully advise that the owner spend one full night sleeping in that room, and I can't imagine that he/she would not make an immediate call to the nearest mattress store in the morning to purchase a new one(s). Also, by the third night before we went to dinner I had to go downstairs to speak to someone ask for fresh soap. My husband and I spent 3 days sharing one very tiny square of soap for the shower. The second tiny bar was kept at our sink for washing our hands. By day 3 we were literally using a chip of soap. I've never been in an inn or hotel where the tiny hotel soap is not refreshed everyday. Let alone after 3 days of 2 people sharing it.

I had a wonderful stay. Accomodations are very good. Although the room I stayed faces the street and there are some noise.
Staff were very kind and educated.
The bad experience was related to the fact that my sunglasses disappeared misteriously. (Not inside the room). Probably in the garden or in the breakfast table...
Really not something expected from a place like this...

All Hamptons B&Bs wish they were the Baker House. This spot is the real deal. They can do no wrong. I wish I had the sense and taste of their interior designer (love the decor)! And, the breakfast is not to be missed.

My husband and I visited the Baker House for a long weekend. The hotel is beautiful, and the staff is very friendly. We stayed in the Maidstone room and despite being told the hotel was completely booked we felt as though we were the only couple there. Although the hotel is located close to the bustling center of town both the hotel and it's grounds are quiet and peaceful. The spa is great and if you book a treatment you will have the luxury of having the spa all to yourself. There are plenty of restaurants nearby so it's not a sacrifice not having a restaurant located in the hotel. The Breakfast served every morning was to die for, pastries, eggs, pancakes all wonderfully cooked. My husband and I travel extensively and have to stayed at some of the best hotels both in the US and Europe and we both agree the Maidstone is amazing and worth every penny.