I wasn't sure about writing this review. I did not want to "Let the secret out" about our pleasant stay so the Painter's Inn would be sold out next time I called. I am in my mid-forties and have been visiting West Point since the age of eight with my parents. I have stayed at numerous locations form Highland Falls to Newburgh. My wife and I were looking for a place to stay and I called Painter's Inn because of the close proximity to the Military Academy. Let me make clear the Inn is a restaurant first with limited rooms second. They had one room left (their Suite), I booked it
with dinner reservations.
When we arrived around 7:30pm on Friday evening. The restaurant was bustling, in fact so busy that people were waiting for tables at the 80 seat restaurant. We were escorted to our room up the stairs. The room was older (of course it is in an old Inn), but it was pleasantly updated with track lighting and artwork (see pictures I added). The suite had a bedroom; rustic bar nook; spare room with couch, table, and fridge; a older but clean bathroom. It was kept very nice!
The staff then walked us down the stairs and showed me how to work the lock on the front door. You see the restaurant stops serving at 10:30pm and the bar closes around midnight. The restaurant does not open till 11:30am and staff do not sleep over in the restaurant. So when the other review says they do not have a 'maid staff', it is true you cannot get an
ironing board at 6:00am. However, they do have a staff that clean the rooms, make the beds, with our room being very clean and pleasant. In the morning when checking out you just leave the key on the front counter and pull the front door closed.
We unpacked and went to the restaurant for a nice dinner. It is Zagat rated for both food and staff as a 'Good to Very Good' which I think is right in line. It is not an expensive top of the line New York city restaurant but we were very pleasantly surprised with the food. The dinner crowd was mixed from families, older couples on dates, and people in their twenties getting ready to go out after. After we had drinks at the bar discussing our pleasant surprise and chatted with the nice staff. Very relaxed and happy we retired to our room without having to worry about drinking and driving.
So take it from one that has visited the area for years and travels a fair amount for business. If you are looking for the Ritz-Carlton the Painter's Inn is not. But, if you want a reasonably priced clean room, a restaurant with good food, and a nice atmosphere with pleasant staff .....
I think you will be hard pressed to find better in the area.
