We stayed in John's cabin which was a lot more rustic than the pictures showed. It reeked of smoke when we walked in and i figured out why when we started a fire. The wood burning fireplace doesnt seem to have a flue so you have to keep the glass shut and the smell has no place to go really. the bathroom was tiny and the shower was scary, we only stayed one night so i didnt have to use it thankfully. the hot tub was lovely, we had plenty of hot water and enjoyed it! we heard from 2 other couples that there hot tub's were either not working or didn't have enough hot water to fill them up, that would have been VERY upsetting to me! Anyhow, if we stayed in the summer I would have enjoyed the cabin more to have the windows open and enjoy the lovely view of the lake.. however, the $300 price tag on the room is a bit steep for what you get!
the tea time was lovely.. lots of options and good apps. we did the murder mystery dinner and i was not impressed. this was our first time doing any murder mystery type thing and i felt like it was very unorganized and not really explained. we were originally supposed to be in a large room with a circular type table but there was a bigger group in there so we were moved to a long rectangular table which made it hard to hear people at the opposite ends. it was really hard to eat your food while doing the murder mystery.. all four of us in our group were frustrated with it. the soup and salad were delicious, i had the chicken and it was cold as well as the green beans and baked potato. the desert was pretty good. i thought the service was great.. no complaints at all.
breakfast was served at 9 and very different than any other b&b i have stayed at. everyone was waiting in the lobby, they had coffee and tea available so most were just chatting. we were invited into the dining area at 9a and were served coffee, juice, water and fruit. shortly after we were served muffins and then a baked french toast thing with blueberries and some very gross sausage links. 3 issues with breakfast.. for about 20 minutes an older man who was the son of john spicer talked on and on about the history of the inn. i wouldnt have minded hearing that over tea in the afternoon but first thing in the morning when i want to eat, not fun. there were no shades on the windows so the sun was blaring right into my eyes.. i was not the only one annoyed with this. it would have been nicer if you could come to breakfast between a time frame like 8 - 10 and they had a few more options like toast, cereal and oatmeal. i am not a huge breakfast eater and would have been overly happy with juice, toast, maybe some yogurt.
the other couple we were with stayed in williams room.. very cute. small but nicely decorated. their hot tub was working and they loved it!
