I've stayed at Harbour View Inn several times over the past 5 or 6 years, and it is generally my first choice when travelling to Mackinac Island. The rooms are nice, modern and comfortable, yet the hotel itself feels quite historic, which is important on Mackinac. The breakfast is plentiful and the location can't be beat. It is just off the downtown, so it's quiet and has a wonderful view. The hotel used to have a great big hot tub in the center garden, which was fabulous. It is no longer there, but I would hope they would consider replacing it - that made my stays at Harbour View even more enjoyable and I find I miss being able to relax with a glass of wine, listen to the clip-clop of the horses in the distance, and appreciate Harobour View's lovely garden.
While I do like this hotel, my last stay was not my favorite due to a few things that could be easily corrected. First, we came in on the Ferry and went to the hotel, along with several other couples, but our room was not ready. The other rooms were ready, but we waited for over an hour for it to be cleaned, and I felt I had to constantly check with the desk staff - they didn't seem interested in letting me know right away, or in making sure the staff were getting the room done, or even in offering us another room. It was pouring rain so there was nothing to do but wait until the room was ready so we could change, etc.
When I originally reserved the room, the lowest price option was not available, so I paid an additional charge for the next level. I actually prefer the rooms in the Carriage House, which are the least expensive. They are larger and more comfortable than the room we had, which was ground level in the main building. It seemed small and the sink area was very small. I'll be sure to call earlier to make my reservation next time. Also, there was a box of uneaten carryout in the room when we checked in. Housekeeping came immediately after I called to remove it, but no other apology or action was given for this yucky discovery.
If you're travelling to Mackinac Island, this hotel is a good choice. I've stayed in several others and would only try a different hotel if I were persuaded by a special offer.
- Harbor View Hotel
- Harbor View Mackinac Island
