I went to the Vineyard in early June for a fishing charter. I was looking for an inexpensive room and I was hoping for pre-season rates. I was disappointed in this regard, as the room was about double what I'd expect to pay in other locales. However, everything on Martha's Vineyard costs more, so I wasn't too surprised.

The room was clean and comfortable, and offered a small fridge, a microwave, and a coffee pot. The bed was great and it was quiet at night. I was pleased with my stay even though the Vineyard prices were higher than I'm used to.

Everywhere was booked on the island and made a reservation here but I never made it to the hotel because of how poor the costumer service was. when i made the reservation i was told i could cancel up to the day of, i got the confirmation email and see there is a 14 day cancellation policy. not what i am told. breakfast is included with your stay but i have a soy and dairy allergy, along with being a Celiac so no gluten. I email about accommodating these medically imposed dietary restrictions and am told that my reservation is now canceled. My husband emails and the manager says oh i am sorry about the confusion but there is a stop and shop across the st, help yourself. wow! you could discount the rate or try in the smallest bit to do something. a simple cup of coffee and a plain egg omelet would have cured it, i didn't ask for an 7 course gourmet meal. i emailed corporate and went elsewhere. i can't imagine what my actual stay would have been had i stayed there!

Very clean. I stayed in room 113 one night and 204 the next. Both were fine, although both had the mushy pillows that I don't like. I didn't ask them it they had other pillows they could have given me though. The staff was extremely nice, courteous and helpful. The hotel has washer and dryer facilities that guests can use, free continental breakfast and a computer for guests to use. No fitness facilities, but you can get a good workout by just walking around the area. No room service, but the hotel is attached to (and has a separate entrance to) a restaurant that you can call and order takeout. No elevator, so I had to bump my suitcase up to the 2nd floor!

My wife and I stayed overnight Saturday on a quick trip to the island. Room was just what we needed: clean, large, reasonably priced and accepted one night booking. My wife liked the large bathroom counter. Ask for a room on the 2nd floor (no elevator) because rooms have vaulted ceilings with the design of this 2 story hotel. Made the room even more spacious and bright. Free continental breakfast had the basics - good for a quick start to the day. Definitely would stay again - if my wife was pleased then they certainly did a good job for us. Also we found a great restaurant for dinner just down the street (The Square Rigger) - popular with the locals. I'd highly recommend it over the tourist restaurants in Edgartown center.