Really can't add much to the other reviews - this place is fabulous. It's immaculate, the toiletries are high-quality, furnishings clean and comfortable. We stayed in the Cape Pogue suite (#3) and were pleasantly surprised that the room was actually nicer than the photos on their website! There are books in several drawers, which was a nice touch, and fresh flowers on the table when we arrived.

Things I wish I'd known before we went:
1. There is a two-burner stovetop, small sink, apartment sized fridge, microwave, toaster, and coffeepot. High-quality coffee (Godiva convenience packs) and teas provided, as well as salt and pepper and dish soap. Anything else you need can be purchased nearby if you don't bring it with you. Local groceries weren't as pricey as I'd expected. Service for four dishes, silverware, cups and glasses provided, as well as can opener, butcher and paring knives, spatula and serving spoon. One- and two-quart saucepans/lids, 8" frying pan, small casserole in cabinet.
2. Housekeeping service daily, including washing dishes! We'd left some dishes in the sink one morning and they were washed, dried and put away when we returned.
3. Running the microwave, coffeepot and both burners simultaneously tripped a breaker.
4. If you require bright reading light, you might want to bring your own bulb, as the suite has 40w and 60w bulbs (although in the thank-you note we received, the innkeeper said she'd take care of that)

FABULOUS innkeeper and employees - we can't wait to go back!

The location was walking distance to town. The kitchen had everything we needed to make meals! The kids loved being able to sit on the deck . Own parking spot.The housekeeping staff made this a pleasant vaca because each time I returned to my room everything was spotless. Heidi was accomodating when it came to Hurrican Earl. We will return next year! Only good memories of a wonderful vacation in a comfortable "home away from home"!! Thanks to The Lightkeepers Inn................

I just stayed at the Lightkeepers Inn last weekend and my boyfriend and I had a fantastic time. The Inn is very quaint and in a great location close to everything in Edgartown. Had a family room and kitchen, which I wasn't even expecting so there was plenty of room, more than 2 of us needed, but it was still great. We loved our private patio where we enjoyed the sun and played scrabble as the sun was setting. I saw complaints about the construction noise, but this was not an issue, I barely heard anything nor did I care because we were too busy exploring the area anyway. Within walking distance to many great restaurants and the harbor, would def stay there again.

This was our first time to Martha's Vineyard, and we chose the Lightkeepers Inn based on other TA reviews. I was a bit apprehensive, at first, because of the construction across the street and being right on the Chappy ferry line. However, our stay was perfectly comfortable and enjoyable.
Although check-in time is 3 pm, our room was ready when we arrived around noon, and we were able to settle in before exploring. We were in #2, which provided more than enough space for the 4 of us. The location of the inn is really amazing - we took our car, but found we didn't need it at all since everything (restaurants, shops, bike rental) was within walking distance. The kids (ages 4 & 6) enjoyed being able to skip down the street to almost everything we wanted to see and do. Definitely rent bikes and head out on one of the great bike paths!
We left Saturday (just at Tropical Storm Danny was unleashing its torrents), and in our rush to get to the ferry we left behind an iPhone and some socks in one of the drawers. I didn't even realize this until I got voicemail from Pat letting me know she'd found them and would be happy to mail them back to me. When I called her to thank her, I offered to pay for postage, which she politely declined. Now that is what I call great service! This just reinforced our decision to go back to the Lightkeepers Inn next time we're in MV.