So there are several factors that contribute to this rating. First, we arrived in York Beach on a wandering vacation and decided it looked nice and we'd try to stay a couple of days. No reservations, on a Saturday afternoon, in July, Yeah. So, I began calling places starting at the top of the ratings I could browse on my phone and working my way down the list (as ALL were booked) until my battery was drained. I then resorted to just walking along Long Sands beachfront and stopping at the hotel desks. At the York Harbor Motel and Cottages I got a "Yes, we have one room left", yay! The price? $260 for one night or $200 a night for 2 nights, ouch! Husband and I conferred for 2 minutes and decided we would suck it up and stay.
Well, the room ended up being a "studio cottage" which turned out to be a low-ceilinged single room with everything: bed, bureau, nightstand, TV, clothing rack, kitchen, table and chairs. Not really much "moving around" room. Separated by a door was the small bathroom (tiny vanity, no tub). There was also a very small, screened porch on the front. The kitchen came with everything you might need for a longer stay, plates, cups, bowls, fridge, microwave, coffee maker etc. The bed was terrible, it sagged in the middle and I think it was a full size, barely large enough for two normal adults to share comfortably. Linens were clean, but old and worn. The carpet smelled musty. Our unit had a window air conditioner that barely cooled the room at full blast. I guess only some of the units here have A/C, so if that is important to you, make sure you know what you are getting.
There is a small pool on the property, but it's selling point is really the proximity to the beach (across the street). The beach here is beautiful, but whoa, crazy crowded on July weekends.
They include a $6 breakfast coupon for the Lobster Cove Restaurant (a block away) for each adult in the room, food was decent there. The lady that was manning the desk when we checked in was very friendly and extremely helpful, the one the next day was neither of the above. This room would have been fine for $60 a night, even $100 at the tops, but was really substandard for the price we paid. Of course, it's all about supply and demand, and that weekend there was plenty of demand, right after we paid for the room someone came in asking if they had any vacancies. Would I come back to York Harbor? Yes! Would I stay here again? No, thank you.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC