This is my second review of Cocount Grove/Oasis... And my reaction is still the same. In the ever changing island of Key West, I think that Coconut Grove remains a great option for those not wanting to stay at Island House.
Alexanders is nice, but is not exclusively men or gay, if that is what you are looking for.
Island House is fun to visit, but don't think it's the best place for me to stay.
Big Ruby's is too close to Duval.
Equator is just feeling run down, and is attracting a much older crowd.
That leaves Coconut Grove. If you have the choice, make sure and get a room in Coconut Grove. It is the most recently remodeled, and is the winner for that reason.
For anyone considering going, just know that you are not going to be at a luxury resort. The staff is not top notch, is not aggressively friendly or helpful... it's all just adequate. BUT the guys that stay there are great, you will always meet new friends, can sunbathe nude, etc. etc.
