The rooms are nice and clean, the service friendly and the pool area is above average. detractors are (i) poor location - you need to drive to get anywhere and parking in Key West is expensive and (ii) the smoke alarm went off for no reason around 1 AM.

This was our second trip to the Inn of Key West. The first time was two years ago Christmas week. My husband and I adore this Inn. The rooms are lovely and well appointed. The staff is very helpful and friendly. The location is just a few minutes from town, just perfect. The pool area is the best that Key West has to offer including all the 5 star hotels on the island. In our opinion, you can't find a better Inn on the whole entire island and look forward to many more visits in the future.

All of the hotel staff were great. Helpful and friendly. Our room was great! Very clean, well appointed and comfortable. The pool area was very nice and relaxing. We had a good meal delivered to our room later at night from a local Chinese restaurant the hotel recommended. The breakfast at the hotel was very good and reasonably priced. All in all a very pleasant, relaxing well accommodated hotel away from the crowds and hubbub of downtown. Would highly recommend and would definitely stay here again! I loved coffee on the lanai in the am watching the ibis playing in the parking lot.

We found overpriced rooms with what looks like black mold on the ceiling and walls plus the walls were so thin we heard the radio from the outdoor cafe area. Then, in the morning the thin walls were not helped by the traffic of people marching back and forth. When the vioces turned to yelling I look out the door to see who could be so rude to find only the mango red shirts of the hotel staff!
The pool was the best feature.

The hotel location South side of N. Roosevelt is on an inside turn making the left turn towards old Key West area a nearly blind turn onto the always busy traffic.
Also near IHOP which might make breakfast easy for some.