In key west i truly found this hotel as one of the best value.
It may be a couple of miles from the heart of the city but there are municipal parking garages in the city center which charges only $13/day. This way it's always nice to stay here and save hundreds of dollars which other downtown hotels charges.
Rooms are Clean with wonderful view of the sea. Very nice Hot breakfast was served in the morning.
Most important is the excellent staff.I reached at 12 Am and my room was ready. Requested a microwave for my baby and it was immediately fulfilled.They have also a nice pool and a tiki bar where every evening we enjoyed a couple of drinks. Overall wonderful amenities and experience in Key West.I would definitely stay here again in my next trip.

Stayed in Dec 2010-family of 4. We checked in and received an upgrade to a two room suite w/fridge and giant bed-same cost as a regular room. Bed was comfy, sleep couch not so much. Pool area is lovely and heated, nice view from room overlooking water and highway. Helpful staff, concierge. Breakfast was so so, nice waffle maker but everything else seemed to be frozen and defrosted-expected better. Breakfast was very crowded and busy, hotel was packed with many foreign tourists. Taxi/bus ride to downtown Key West, need a car to really get around from the hotel. Taxis are expensive.

From reading the other reviews, I should have visited Stephanie at "splash". The truth is that the location is bad, The gangways are worn, There are cracks in the ceiling. All this would be OK if the price was under $100 - but it isn't.

The hotel is located on busy US Route 1 in Key West. Because of the nice water views we opted for a room with views of the water; be mindful however that rooms on the water side also face busy US Route 1 and traffic including motor scooters, trucks, buses etc. For a quieter room choose rooms facing the pool area. The staff is very friendly, the complimentary breakfast is good, and the pool and exercise room are nice. Parking is free and if you purchase tickets on the Old Town Trolley (sales booth located a short walk from the hotel) you can avoid driving in the historic district and paying for parking. Our room was on the fifth floor with great views, the room itself was not up to usual Comfort Inn standards but was clean. It needs upgrading in the bathroom especially the shower and bathtub. The beds were Select Comfort and comfortable. All in all we enjoyed our stay there and would lodge there again.