We went to Mystic for new year eve with another couple friend. Whaler's Inn was one of the few places where there were rooms available and the reviews were not too bad, so we made the reservation. Overall I was not very happy with the stay quality vs the prices they charge. Here are pros and cons of staying here:
Pros:
1) Excellent location: Whaler's inn is right in the downtown area and all the good restaurants, drawbridge and boardwalk is few steps away.
2) Parking: They have a decent sized parking lot and parking is free.
3) Front desk people were very pleasent and supportive.
Cons:
1) Breakfast was boring. We took one look and decided to move out for breakfast.
2) Room walls are paper thin. We could hear a guy snoring next door at night. That was horrible.
3) Rooms are poorly lit. We had room #26 and our friends had #28 in the main building. Ours was absolutely dark. There were only 2 small side table lamps and we had to struggle to find stuff out of our suitcase.
4) Floors were creaky. So every time someone moved in corridor, we could feel the ground shaking.
5) Beds were very uncomfortable. It was a problem in both the rooms we had.
There are lot of other options around this area that might be better. For a small town like Mystic, I believe even if the hotel is not in downtown, that should not matter as most of the places are within walking distances.
