My husband and I stayed at the New Sheridan for 7 nights in January. Our overall experience was excellent.
Room: The room was very clean and well-appointed, with everything I could want easily at-hand: good heat, big bathroom with very hot water, super comfortable bed and pillows, plenty of towels, hair drier, alarm clock, wireless access, hot-tubs, big bath-robes, etc.
Ski Accomodations: Ski equipment storage was well-considered: mud-room lockers, boot warmers, elevators, etc. The walk to the Oak Street Lift and Gondala was only three blocks. Ask at the hotel desk about lift ticket discounts.
Food & Drink: The hotel has a casual, happening bar with whatever drinkables you might desire at a reasonable price for generous pours. As for food, there is a classy chop-house restaurant with wine bar if you should feel in the mood to have an upscale dinner.
Management: The hotel is managed with relaxed expertise by Team Bo and Mike, who were very gracious and accomodating. Finally, I would add that the maid service is excellent and consistent with fresh linens and towels.
In conclusion: If you can find a ski-in, ski-out for a comparable price, it would be worth considering. However, given the quality of the room and the proximity of the Telluride offerings, we can't think of any reason to consider staying elsewhere.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC