This hotel has all the basic amenities and does the job for a quick stay. The staff were actually very friendly and nice and down to earth (translation: local twenty-something types with a somewhat laid back attitude, plus the parent-like managers). Reservations can be made online and it's all convenient. They also still use room keys which is a nice, classic touch.

It's a little outdated with the tube TV, simple decor and bedding but it's not what I'd call shabby. Just simple. For example, our king room was spacious and equipped with a tiny kitchenette (stove! microwave! fridge! sink! very 70's!) but it didn't have a duvet on the bed, plush pillows or a comfy armchair. (There was a table with 3 sitting chairs, bench, closet, pullout ironing board in the room, iron, hairdryer. Make sure you request a room on "the quiet side" which means away from the pool area where people can hang out into the evening.)

When my hubs and I stay up in Wine Country we're usually prepared to spend at least $200-250 per night + hotel taxes. Our usual place wasn't available (Indian Springs Resort and Spa), so we had to check out something new. We weren't disappointed in the John Muir as mainly a place to crash, get ready for the semi-formal wedding we were attending and spend just a little downtime before and after.

A very reasonable deal for the Napa Valley considering Wine Country premium costs. This is perfect for adults who will be too busy hiking, wine tasting, dining out and shopping (and want to spend their $$$ on that rather than a hotel room). Or, a decent choice for posse on a budget (it's right off the highway with cheap eats nearby) who want to chill and don't mind the well-attended but dated atmosphere. The good thing is in California, stuff is slow to decay...

I would recommend this place to friends that just needs a simple room versus a romantic high end hideaway.

The location is great for this motel, however, it is tired and could use a good renovation. They may also want to consider adding better food to their complimentary breakfast and adding wine glasses to the room. They are in Napa, so that would be a good touch.

John Muir Inn was clean but it desperately needs attention. Paint, new carpet, and updated furniture would help a great deal. It does have a great location but there are properties on VRBO that are much nicer and cheaper.

Stayed here for a wedding in Napa. I wasn't impressed with the hotel. It was like a Motel 6 but at the cost of a Marriott. Decor was old, beds we soft and you can feel springs moving. Should have spent the extra $$ to stay at the Marriott right down the street.