We stayed here on our honeymoon in 1983, and this was our first time back to Mendocino since. We thought it would be fun to stay in the same place, and after reading the reviews on TA, I happily booked us. I got a great off-season deal (three nights for the price of two), but the prices are pretty competitive all the time.
Best things, in order:
(1) The breakfasts are AMAZING. Delicious & beautifully presented. Imagine having breakfast in the fanciest hotel restaurant you can think of. Now imagine it sitting at your own little table at a bay window looking out over the ocean. That's our experience.
(2) The location is perfect. You don't even need to move your car.
(3) The service and hospitality are topnotch, everything you would want and then some. Besides the breakfast, there's tea, cookies, nuts, and such in the afternoon (homebaked cookies!), sherry in the parlor, cold drinks in a common fridge, etc. All the thoughtful little touches. In our room we had a nice fire laid everyday, a mini-fridge, and excellent WiFi (no TV, though).
A couple of notes: You can ask for coffee to brought a bit earlier if you can't wait until 9:00 when breakfast is come. They deliver a coffee service along with the SF Chronicle. If even that's not enough, there's an excellent coffee bar that opens at 6 a.m. a short block away.
If waiting for breakfast is a problem for you, just bring along a few granola bars or get some yogurt to put in the fridge. But don't eat too much because the breakfast is absolutely worth the wait.
We were in the Bessie Strauss room, and we agree with others that the sloping bed took some getting used to. We managed, but I think they will remove the feather bed mattress cover on request if you're fussy about the bed.
This is really a wonderful place, and all the other rave reviews in TA were spot-on.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC