Having had the privilege of staying at many of the world's finest (and some of the worst) hotels, I was still knocked out by the beauty, splendid design and attention to detail of this establishment. For my tastes and my wife's, the Lodge was close to perfect and we absolutely would go back, if the travel gods took us near La Jolla again. That said, I must be clear: If your tastes run to the Pierre or Sherry in their heydays, the Lodge isn't for you. There's no glitz. Instead, you get a masterful take on California Craftsman-era architecture and interior design: Greene and Greene, but with more light. The rooms are stunners, furnished with Stickley and Roycroft-style items (and William Morris wallpaper in the bathrooms). The spa, in a nod to Scotland's golf tradition, uses Charles Rennie McIntosh reproductions. Artwork, both real and made-to-order, is handsome--with some truly superb California paintings here and there...plus a hallway of original framed German Jugendstil "Jugend" magazine covers. Brilliant design and workmanship throughout. For me, this is the ultimate "upscale male" type of furnishing, but my wife found it remarkably seductive, as well. Okay, so you're not into Craftsman stuff or architecture. Well, you've got the best public golf course in the USA (not my thing--I go in for real sports). The restaurant, Valentien's, is terrific. The entire staff is gracious, helpful and seem to actually like working there...if only this lodge were in a true rural setting, it would be perfect. Only downside for us is that it's sandwiched between the golf course--which keeps you from approaching the cliffs and the sea--and a busy main road and research park. While the Torry Pines State Park is only a three-quarter-mile walk to the north, it's a small and very crowded park (great for morning runs, though). All that said, this is a marvelous hotel, an instant favorite with us, a grander version of another favorite of ours, the Stephanie Inn in Cannon Beach, Oregon, and a grandchild of my favorite hotel in the world, the Ahwanee in Yosemite (for the authentic architecture and design--and the magnificent location--Sorrento, eat your heart out). Really, the Lodge is an amazing place--and an astonishing monument to fine taste, given that this is, after all, La Jolla, the land of glitz, golf and Spandex. I should add that my wife and I generally maximize our time outdoors, but loved this hotel so much we spent extra hours in the room--very romantic place, too.
Room Tip: Absolutely spring for an ocean-view room--and ask for one on the fifth floor, if you want a real vie...
See more room tips
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC