Would I stay here again? You bet. In fact it has become a "birthday" treat for myself, and a welcomed getaway for my wife and I both over the past 4years (many times twice a year). We have stayed previously at other properties in Cambria, and NONE compare to the Blue Whale. I have colleagues who have stayed at other locations both on Moonstone Beach Dr and in town, and when we compare notes, there is NO comparison.
How can you compare the Blue Whale's made from scratch "gourmet" 2 course breakfast each morning to at worst (and verified by talking to colleagues) warehouse club brought danish and muffins and canned OJ? (Yes there are inn's along Moonstone Dr that do this, at a price equal to a nights stay at the Blue Whale Inn, picture included of one of our brekfasts).
The views are magnificent from the dining room (see attached photo), the inn is large enough to offer extra comfort and services, yet small enough that the Inn Keepers always greet you by name! On the later, Jay and Karen are the BEST. We make sure we book at least one or more of our nights when they are on duty, and in turn are always rewarded with a warm handshake and greeting that makes us feel "at home". And its not just us they do this for, but for each and every guest at this inn.
The inn has changed owners at least twice since we've started staying here, but Jay and Karen have been the single thread that's kept the inn grounded and one of the reasons we keep coming back.
The rooms (there are 7) are all each unique (no cookie cutter here) and each has its own Charm and personality. There is 1 that closer to the equipment room that might get noisy during the day, so if you plan to stay in your room during the day ask for one of the rooms 1-5 or the only one we have not stayed in the "suite". But each is very comfortable, and offers a restful night no matter the room. (We've stayed in room 6, closest to the equipment room, and it too is very comfortable) While the decor maybe a little too "country cottage" for my personal taste, none are so much that it distracts or offends. Again there just very comfortable. Being a traveler on business, and lucky enough that my company will allow me to stay in places like the 4 Seasons or Ritz-Carltons' I can confidently say the rooms here are as comfortable and better equipped than those at the aforementioned 5 star locations.
Am I alone in this opinion? No. Everytime I've stayed, EVERY guest we speak with at the inn always tell us the EXACT same thing.
Having seen the 2 "negative reviews" listed here, I felt I had to say something to offset what was obviously a "fluke" and not representative of my stays and from what I can gather the stays of other guests while we've been at the inn.
Looking forward to our next stay at the inn in a few months!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC