We have been staying at the Calistoga Inn for nearly 15 years and had not been there for three years. We were excited to go back and had no idea about the DJ and live music situation. The staff never mentioned it on the phone and boy were we in for a change. We had invited another couple to meet us there figuring it would be a quaint and quirky place just like always. What a disaster. The music was so loud there was no place to hide. We demanded a refund for the coming night that we had paid for and headed for the Comfort Inn up the street which was extremely quiet. The Inn is no longer in good shape and is evident by duct tape holding toilet tanks together and the insides of the rooms look as though no one has kept them in good repair. Too bad, this used to be a neat place. Now after all these years of being a patron we will never go back.

We are a couple in the 50 ies. We like to travel within the USA and Calistoga is surely a place to see. It is true that the hotel description on the net is correct. The showers are "shared" but clean and acceptable. I think they could improve a bit the sink that is in the room. A bit too small (it is a hand wash sink". Be carefull to ask a room at the rear / back of the building because there is heavy trafic and it is difficult to sleep after 5 AM!.
If you want to swim, there is a nice swimming pool not far from the hotel (municipality). So we can say that we liked it,

Friendly Staff and very CLEAN Inn. I read the reviews about the nightlife below my room and I will write that they have a GREAT sound system. ;-) The continental breakfast satisfied my pre-wine tasing exercise by supplying enough nutrition. The rooms were well equipped for my stay and the sink was the added touch. Many compliments to the cuisine and decor in the dining room. I look forward to staying with you again.

We booked one night at the last minute and very much enjoyed our stay. We were warned up front that the bar was open until 2.30 and that the bathrooms were shared. Overall the rooms and bathrooms were clean and the beds comfortable and the help-yourself continental breakfast perfecty satisfactory. The bar was noisy until around 1.30 but we were fine with it as we had been informed. Overall we felt it was good value, but not suitable for anyone looking for a quiet night.