We had an enjoyable stay in the Pinetop area, including our seven nights the PVC at the Roundhouse Resort. Like another reviewer mentioned, the PVC at the Roundhouse Resort is not he 'Roundhouse Resort'. The Roundhouse Resort is an older property of hotel type rooms. The PVC at the Roundhouse Resort is a timeshare type property with individual cabins.
The 'cabins' are really manufactured homes with log siding. The cabins are very nice, large and clean. Well equipped in all aspects with one big exception - no air conditioning. Even at 7000 feet, Pinetop still gets warm, or some might say hot. No A/C would probably keep us from returning. With kids who need to take midday naps, it's tough inside a stuffy cabin. If the cabin had air conditioning I would be happy to rate the cabin as an A. Without A/C, definitly a lower rating.
Don't expect your 'cabin' to be in a nature setting. Think more or an RV park type personal space setting. The 'cabins' are close to each other and there is a busy road near the property. Our 'cabin' was one of the furthest from the road, and we could hear road noise throughout the night through our open windows (no A/C). There is a fire station accross from the property. There were a number of cabins that directly backed the road. I definitly would not want to stay in any of those.
The reality of a stay in Pinetop is that you get to explore the amazing forests. The PVC is a great launching point for this. With small children, we wanted to find a river to let the kids wade in. We found river wading nirvana about 20 minutes from the PVC.
The north fork of the White river on the Apache reservation was picture postcard perfect. Unspoiled, easy access, beautful clear and cool - a perfect escape!
We also vistied Greer - never pass up a steak at Molly Butler lodge and visited Hawley Lake - almost as big as Big Lake, and a much prettier setting. The nine mile drive on SR 473 is pretty in itself. Hawley lake at 8300 feet was very pretty. It was too bad that the boat dock workers didn't show up the day we were there, as we wnated to rent a boat and take it out on the lake.
If the cabins had A/C, more space and trees between you and your neigbors and there was no road noise this would be a perfect vacation spot. Even with these issues, we had an enjoyable time at the PVS at the Roundhouse Resort.
One last item - the staff was very helpful and friendly.
- Pvc At Roundhouse Hotel
