This was a really disappointing experience after booking 8 months ahead on the basis of the previous Trip Advisor reviews, and receiving friendly assistance from Sabina. This was going to be a family reunion for Christmas with our grown-up children travelling from different continents. We had made a reservation for 8 nights but one uncomfortable night was enough. We left and headed back north. To be fair, one problem was the timing of our visit in December. We expected the rainy season to be over. It was not. On the evening we arrived, we had three solid hours of rain. Obviously, not the owner's faulty, but a warning to other potential visitors to the area at this time of year. Despite its splendid beach, Dominical is also really a group of houses and bars and nothing to write home about.
We had requested the cottage but this property was dingy, outdated and shabby. We stayed the night in the Mango rooms, a group of three non-private rooms in one building with a veranda. At $60 per person per night + 13% tax, these rooms are not good value; they are cramped and basic, the bed is uncomfortable, and the shower produced neither hot water nor a reasonable rate of flow (The owner warned us about the latter problem despite the brochure offering a "hot shower".) The description of the property as offering "well-appointed" rooms is simply not accurate. We all had an uncomfortable night - disturbed by a mixture of cold temperature, uncomfortable beds, baying dogs (Sabina has several), and the cabins' location 200 metres from the Pan-American Highway, along which noisy heavy trucks pass through the night.
Other parts of the Alma de Hatillo website are also quite misleading. While displaying attractive pictures of the pool, breakfast area, and yoga studio, the site misleadingly gives the sense of space i.e. that the cabins are spread out on a fairly large property. They are not. Indeed, the general sense we had was claustrophobic and a lack of sunlight. All the buildings are pretty close together, and each contain individual rooms next to one another. The site speaks of offering an evening meal (at extra cost) but Sabina told us she did not cook and was thankful that her son (who evidently could cook) had just arrived from Belgium. The dingy cottage in which we had originally planned to stay offered cooking facilities but the other rooms do not. Although there is a well-stocked supermarket in Dominical, the rooms only have tiny fridges in which to store food. So, visitors faced the prospect of traipsing out for lunch and dinner to one of the bars in Dominical. Continental breakfast was included, was OK, but nothing to write home about. Indeed, more generally, this accommodation really needs to offer more than it does.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC