My boyfriend and I just spent almost two weeks in Costa Rica, almost exclusively on the Caribbean-side, in Puerto Viejo. We stayed at two places in Puerto Viejo, simply to get a better feel for the area. We loved both places, however, El Tucan Lodge was definitely the better value. Nina and Wolfgang are very welcoming hosts, along their two dogs, Maximilius and Vicky. Nina made us a wonderful breakfast every morning, including when we had to be up and ready to leave by 6:30 a.m. to catch our tour bus to Tortuguero National Park.
They have bikes you can rent at a very reasonable rate. I recommend renting the bikes, the lodge is 800 meters off the main road into the jungle. We enjoyed the solitude and quiet that being off the main road provided. That said, we did use taxis to get home after having dinner in Puerto Viejo (only because it was dark, we didn't have bike lights, nor know the pot-holes in the road). Catching a taxi is neither difficult or expensive. The bikes we useful in our adventures to the different beaches -- Cocheles and PV are very close, while Punta Uva (which is gorgeous) is within easy biking distance. BIG RECOMMENDATION: If you are going to bike in PV (which I think is the best way to get around) bring some bike lights with you, front and rear.
The rooms are quaint, rustic and clean. The shower was great - large with good pressure. We very much enjoyed being woken by the howlers at 4 a.m., although I really think that happens everywhere in PV as it also occurred at our other lodge. The deck outside our room was great, we would spend several hours reading in hammocks, listening to wildlife in the jungle and watching for birds and monkeys.
If you don't like traditional resorts, rather, appreciate genuine hospitality, rustic and clean lodges, being off-the-beaten-trail, and surrounded by various cultures, you will love El Tucan Lodge. Although from the US, my boyfriend speaks fluent German and delighted in speaking German with Wolfgang and Irene during our stay. Because the owners are German, but also speak French, English and Spanish, the guests that stay here are very diverse themselves. While they do not offer a dinner, they do have a great patio on which you are served breakfast and can purchase beer and wine in the evening and socialize.
We will definitely be returning to PV, and will definitely stay at El Tucan Lodge again.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC