My husband and I stayed at the Local Cave Hotel, in their "luxury suite". We paid ~150 euro/night, and (at the time of booking) thought it was ok because a) it was billed as a luxury suite and the pictures looked great and b) we were staying in a cave (very cool)..... but of course once we reached Goreme we realized that pretty much every single hotel was a "cave hotel".
Positives:
1) location.......I would definitely stay in Goreme if you are going to Cappadocia (as opposed to Urgup or Uchsitar or wherever). Within Goreme, Local Cave hotel is nicely situated a few minutes walk to the shops and Goreme Open Air museum is within walking distance (~15-20 min walk).
2) swimming pool - although we ourselves didn't use the pool, other guests did and it appeared that not very many hotels have pools in Goreme. There was a nice sitting area (lounge chairs, cushions, with wifi in the central area)
3) Jihan, one of the staff, was very nice
Negatives
1) the bathroom. The bathroom looks really luxurious......but then you try to use it. There is no shower door!! (It was apparently broken and never replaced)...so you are standing under the spray, one side warm while your other side is freezing -- it is very very cool in the cave! Moreover, because there is no door, a large portion of the bathroom floor gets sopping wet. It's also very dim in the bathroom, which makes it hard to use during morning routines. There is also no alarm clock in the bedroom.
2) the bees and wasps at breakfast........hard to enjoy your breakfast while trying to avoid being stung. The breakfast itself seemed ok, but the milk was WARM (ugh, I almost threw up) and both my husband and I got severe upset stomach from it (so we were less inclined to eat breakfast on other days)
3) Wifi doesn't work in the rooms....only outside (not a big problem for us as we just went and sat by the pool and checked our email, but if you are staying there when it's cold, it may be a problem for you
4) Harun's attitude #1.... Harun was very welcoming towards us when we first arrrived. However when it became clear that we were not going to book trips through him, or if we did it was at the places we wanted (not necessarily where he wanted us to book), his attitude changed. Case in point: we use Rick Steves' guides frequently, and watch his show. I saw a clip where he was using Butterfly Balloons to go ballooning over Cappadocia. When we asked Harun to book through Butterfly, he told us they didn't have space and wanted us to use Royal Balloons. We said no,, we'll wait and see if a spot opens on Butterfly (as we had a few days there). I then emailed Butterfly enquiring of availability. Suddenly Butterfly had spots open.... at first I thought this could be just coincidence, but later experiences made me change my mind.
5)Harun's attitude #2 ... we booked a car and driver for a day to see other parts of Cappadocia (more affordable than paying for 2 people to get a tour). We did not konw that Harun would be the driver.........suffice to say my husband and I refer to this experience as the "Speed Tour of Cappadocia". Harun treated us as though we were an annoyance.
6) Harun's attitude #3... we asked Harun to book transport to the Kayseri airport so that we could be there 90 min prior, as was recommended through our reading. Harun insisted that 90 min was not necessary (repeatedly) and booked us transfer. The problem is it definitely was NOT enough time (and the transport being late didn't help). we literally had 4 MINUTES to spare while trying to get on our flight (9am flight and the only other flight out was at 4:30 pm that day). We almost missed our flight and would have been stuck in the Kayseri airport all day. I am convinced that he simply didn't care.
Overall, we cannot recommend this hotel. There are MANY cave hotels in Goreme - choose another.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC