My husband and I stayed at the Inn in September 2010. We really enjoyed ourselves. As others have already noted, it is directly across the street from the airport but it is not at all noisy. The location is convenient for your arrival/departure, but is not really close to any of the island attractions. You need a car or you can use the shuttle service. In other words, don't think you can stay here and be walking distance to shopping, restaurants, etc.
The breakfast every morning was a very nice bonus. The indoor pool was great too.
The breakfast and shuttle staff were exceptionally friendly. The front desk staff should take a lesson from them! They were the only ones who were a bit discourteous (in particular a really grouchy woman up front one morning!). But, in all, I still wouldn't discourage a stay at this Inn.
Also, there really isn't a dinner menu at the bar, so if you do stay there, be sure to eat dinner before you return to the Inn.
This is not the Ritz, and you can surely find more elegant accommodations on Nantucket, but you'll really pay for it. I would recommend the Inn for an affordable stay on Nantucket.
