I am sure this hotel is great, but they sure did ruin my 1 night stay.
PROS:
1. Location is really convenient to a cheap mall for some quick purchases
2. The management staff are very well trained. Very proactive, jump in to help guests. However, th front line staff are horrible
3. Housekeeping is terrific. They do a miracle to make this old hotel look like very clean and fresh.
4. Room service was great. We ordered indina food. The desserts are to die for. Must try - pecan brownie with their home made vanilla ice cream
5. I see many comments about the breakfast at Melt. But i didnt think it was special. Lots of variety, but everytime i took out a plate to get some food, the plate would be dirty! but variety is definitely very good.
6. The bed was beautiful. I have not slept so comfortably in years!
7. The view from the harbour rooms is very nice. You see the amazing sands resort to the left and the entire singapore skyline on the right.
6. And thats about it!
CONS:
1. Check in: the lady was very pleasent, but she got everythign wrong. Firstly i wanted to pay by debit card for the incidentals. She said they would just note down my details and not charge. Later in the day i get a call from the reception that they wil have to charge me the entire room rate + $200 immediately. It is strange that i am expected to pay the entire room rate a day before i checkout!! I have stayed at several hotels around the world and paid with debit cards. The hotel will generally take the incidentals and on checkout, they will return in cash. The room rate is never charged at check in. Worst thing was when i asked to speak to a manager (because the person who called me was hopelessly lost) terrance called me and pretty much regurgitated the "hotel policy". What happened to the famous mandarin oriental service!
2. The front desk lady very politely asked me if i wanted the newspaper. I asked for the business times and as i write this review from the hotel room at 9 am, no newspaper yet
3. The room is tiny! I would say about 25 square meters. For $550 that is a shame.
4. The room itself is aging. The hotel interiors are nice till the 4th floor, where all the restaurants are. Very tired on the floors with the rooms.
5. Pool staff speak no english. The waiter had me open the menu and point to the pina colada so that he could write it down in his pad. The manager at the pool is terrific. Pity his staff let him down.
6. The bathroom in the room has no door to the WC area. And there is no sound proofing, which can be embarrassing even if you are staying with your wife.
7. There was a large group of tourists at the lobby last evening, and they just sat all around the lobby. I had to fight my way through to get to the lifts. The hotel staff just stood there watching, instead of guiding the guests away to some private area.
8. I am sure that this is a safety code violation, that the hair dryer in the room is within easy distance of the bath tub. I am an architect and i was very surprised that a hotel of his calibre would overlook someing like this.
All in all, i think the mandarin oriental is still going strong only because of their management. They clearly do not have front line staff of the same calibre. The hotel is getting old and worn down. Do yourself a favor, stay at one of the newer hotels, and there are plenty of those to chose from in singapore.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC