We just returned from Caye Caulker and had an amazing trip. I did a lot of research and when we stepped foot into the Iguana Reef I knew that we made the right decision - it is the most beautiful hotel on the island! The property has been so well maintained that it feels like it's brand new. Anne, the office manager, was terrific in answering all of my questions prior to arrival and helping make arrangements to ensure wonderful tours and an overall great stay. The Iguana Reef has the feel of a luxury boutique hotel at a reasonable price, especially since the stay includes breakfast and the use of kayaks.
The hotel is on the back side of the island (perfect for sunsets) which made it more quiet but since the island is so small it was a two minute walk to all the action. There are only a few hotels with pools and the Iguana Reef definitely had the best one! Also, because the beach has been man-made you don't have the same problem with sand fleas that you find elsewhere on the island.
If you are looking for a luxury atmosphere but still want to the laid back experience of Caye Caulker then book a room at the Iguana Reef. By far, it's the best place to stay on the island!
