We had a 10-night winter sojourn at the St Regis Aspen, our second stay here. The first was pre-renovation two years ago so we were keen to see the improvements. The building owner (a Thai businessman we learned) is spending $40m attempting to bring this luxury hotel into the 21st century. We heard all sorts of horror stories about people checking in at the start of the ski season; apparently many rooms had not been completed, causing major capacity constraints. Overflow guests were being sent to The Little Nell…ouch!
It was a bit old and dated but we loved the conventionality of the former décor inherited from Ritz Carlton – ultra-luxe ski-lodge with timber panelling and silk-lined walls, crystal chandeliers, marble floors with Persian rugs etc. Some of that remains and in places makes an uneasy connection to the new look, which is way more contemporary but still solid and restrained. They were sensible not to turn this hotel into a funky “W”.
The most obvious change is the lobby lounge and bar with big central fireplace. We liked the changes but many of our friends did not. Daytime this is a beautiful, sunlit space with views up Aspen Mountain (unfortunately across a barren, charmless courtyard which no doubt comes into its own in summer). Seating was ample and comfortable except for the large, fire-side lounges which had a rigid back at 90° to the cushioned-seat. It was like sitting on a park bench and impossible to slouch in, which is all one can do after a day’s skiing. Mostly the service here was charming and attentive, although on two occasions in the late afternoon we waited 20 minutes before a waitress came to serve us. The other gripe was that in 10 days we were never offered a bowl of nibbles with our après-ski cocktails, and we drank there every day, sometimes pre- and post-dinner. We saw them handed out to others (nuts and dried cranberries) but never to us. The bar food is great though; tasty and delicious with terrific pizzas and massive grilled sandwiches that went down a treat with kids and adults alike. A great alternative for a light and easy dinner or lunch.
The restaurant has been renovated but not too well in our view. We miss the booths and current décor is bland and uninspiring. It looks like a large function room with tables – it was dark and gloomy at breakfast with sunny window seats being the most covetable. We like reading papers at breakfast and this proved challenging in the dimness. The chairs are pre-renovation and are too low, too big and way too uncomfortable. Breakfast buffet was what you’d expect of a 5-star hotel – good ingredients and presentation, a nice spread. We got slugged $30 for three lattes on the first morning. “They were doubles” we were told. Well we didn’t ask for doubles, nor did we ask to be ripped off. Sense prevailed and they were removed from the bill. Kudos to the pastry chef as morning muffins and Danish pastries were exceptional, rivalling anything from France. Oddly, the Danishes were one of the biggest delights we had at the St Regis, possibly its greatest asset! Dinner for eight one night was good with knowledgeable maître d' and sommelier. Only gripe was complete lack of menu options for vegetarian me.
We liked the style of the renovated accommodation – timber floors with inset carpet, grey/brown/autumnal motifs with white timber accents. We had plenty of useful storage but heard complaints that other rooms did not. Great bed, super comfortable but with one glaring omission – there was no bedside table on one side! Nothing. Nowhere to place books, reading glasses, pills, water. We were gob-smacked. Reception soon found us one but the fact we had to ask was astounding. The biggest change is the bathrooms that have been completely redesigned, most notably by knocking out the wall between the bedroom and installing two bi-fold doors. This lets natural light into the bathroom and gives users a view outside. In principle it works but at night the cracks around the bi-folds let too much light into the bedroom. A great stand-alone tub, twin sinks, lots of beautiful marble, separate private shower and loo and great lighting make this a well-appointed bathroom. Not perfect though, with no bench space or shelves to place toiletries. We had to remove the hairdryer from a single draw and use that.
Overall we were very comfortable in the room, despite a few gremlins in housekeeping. One of these was on day three when we had to ask for more shampoo. What 5-star hotel doesn’t re-stock bathroom amenities on a daily basis? Was it an oversight or an austerity drive? On arrival we requested the duvet be replaced by a cotton blanket, duly done at turndown but three days later the duvet reappears and the blanket gone. But the worst was to yet to come. We came back late one night to find that every pillow had a pillow case that was too short, leaving about 4 inches (100mm) of snotty, drool-stained pillow sticking out. Too tired to call housekeeping we capped the exposed ends with unused pillow cases and went to bed. Next morning, horrified by this experience, we called the duty-manager to our room to show him. He agreed it was unacceptable and asked “what can we do to make it up to you?” “Nothing” we said, “we just felt you needed to know”. And it was exactly nothing that we got; no follow-up ‘sorry’, no “have a drink on us”, no personal note from the manager; as if this indiscretion was perfectly acceptable to guests paying $800++ per night for an entry level room. Note to St Regis management: we didn’t tell you this for personal gain, only to improve services and ensure you don’t do it again. However, a little unsolicited contriteness and gratitude might go some way to getting us back next year.
Two final grumbles about the accommodation. They’ve re-used the old Bose bed-side sound systems. Great for what they are but to not have MP3 or iPod connectivity is inexcusable and penny-pinching. Maybe they were in other higher-priced rooms, but not ours. The air-conditioning is only heating in winter. If you want cool you have to open the window. We weren’t too precious about that – opening a window worked for us but reduced the effectiveness of the humidifier.
A big commendation for the laundry service which was exceptional, came back promptly same day, even if taken after 10am. Pricey but no more than expected.
Outdoor amenities consist of a large pool and three big hot-tubs, two of which were full of snow – result of a delayed renovation schedule it would seem. Likewise the landscaping was yet to be completed with ditches and cables exposed nearby. Poolside there is a large outdoor cupboard to hang robes and store towels. It used to be heated….not any more, just run-down, cold and ratty.
The Remède Spa in this hotel is a terrific facility, without doubt the best in town. If not having a treatment, holding Platinum SPG status or being a guest in the “Residences”, entry is expensive at $25 per day. Odd, even a little offensive, that they charge hotel guests an entry fee. The treatments are good, if overpriced, and the relaxation room with oxygen a god-send for those affected by altitude. Separate steam cave and hot-tubs for both sexes plus joint facilities are first class. Again, problems here with the servicing of the facilities. Big problems. The men’s change room was poorly attended, with used towels and robes lying around forever and lockers not restocked after use. Water jugs in hot areas were rarely refilled and used plastic cups left lying around. Most annoyingly there were never any towels. One late afternoon of relaxing in the facilities had me requesting towels four times. Some feeble excuse about the supplier did not cut it. To their credit, there was a big improvement after a complaint to the hotel manager.
Overall, this is actually a good hotel that, at the prices it charges, should be a great hotel. Reception and concierge staff is brilliant, as is the driveway team who shuttle you around town. The ski valets take great care of you and are a joy to come home to after a day on the slopes. Only The Little Nell and the Sky Hotel are more conveniently located to the Gondola, everything else is so convenient.
Yes, we should expect more from this hotel and the St Regis brand, but it deserves to be cut some slack. It is coming out of a huge renovation and needs time to get its groove back. We’ll give it one more try next year, hoping like hell our faith will be restored. But loyalty has its limits, it better be exceptional.
Room Tip: Have patience with this hotel as it comes out of a major renovation. If unhappy with anything, you...
See more room tips
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC