My boyfriend and I got engaged at the Horned Dorset in May of this year. It was the rainy season in PR so the place was virtually empty -- we felt like we had the whole place to ourselves. Our bi-level room was beautifully decorated, the soaps were wonderful, the private plunge pool a slice of heaven.
Our visit to the Horned Dorset restaurant was quite different from other reviews -- we loved everything we ate. I actually ordered the same soup both nights because I loved it so much.
We can't wait to go back.

We have been to this hotel several times with our last visit being 5 years ago when we got engaged over dinner at Aarons. We just visited for our 5th anniversary and stayed 5 days.
There have been extensive renovations to the property with new entrance and "new" villas on the left hand side of the property. There are now 22 villas which are 2 floors with 2 baths and plunge pool. The new villas are very nice and we stayed in one of these units with an ocean view. They have tile/marble and are furnished with antiques.to

Another new development is the ongoing sale of the remaining 17 units-right hand side of property as the "Residences at Horned Dorset". Approximately one third of these have been sold with at least one resale on the market.

The level of service and attention to detail that we experienced previously is no longer present. It's a subtle change but definitely noticeable. There was an "owner" on site and it seemed most of the attention of the staff was directed at them. I guess that is to be expected if you purchase a unit there.

Our biggest disappointment was with Aarons the main restaurant.
On our prior visit we had some of the best meals of our lifetime in this restaurant and were very excited with our return. The food was mediocre at best. Undercooked without much taste we actually sent a dish back to the kitchen. After 2 nights with similar quality food we canceled our meal plan and ate out on the island. We subsequently found out from the staff the Chef Aaron has the left the property. He is now working on Martha's Vineyard. I am not sure this is public knowledge as the staff member seemed reluctant to answer when I asked about Chef Aaron.
Overall the Horned Dorset is a special place for us since we got engaged here. The hotel and surroundings are beautiful. Unfortunately the service has declined and it is unclear whether it's related to the development of the "residences". The restaurant was the biggest disappointment and it is unclear who is running the kitchen. Overall we give it 3 stars down from 5 on our prior stays

We only ate dinner here and the meal was quite expensive. The food was good, but I dont think that it justified the expense. I think you were basically paying for the ambiance and service. Probably wouldn't come back just for a meal. The grounds were beautiful though and if you can afford a room, I think it would be worth it for the whole experience.

Tucked by the beach in a corner of Rincon is this Relais and Chateaux group luxury hotel. It was quite a splurge (almost $ 700 for a night) but it was a special occasion and so we thought, why not, for once? It is a lovely property that provides discreet, luxurious service: you may feel that you are the only ones around on the property, yet the staff is always available and attentive when needed.

The room we had was amazing: it was on two levels, with a plunge pool of our own and beautiful views from the bedroom level. Children are not allowed, and the aim is to have a piece of your own paradise, quiet and secluded. There are no televisions either. There have a couple of beautiful pools, the property is lush green, and in the evenings you can enjoy spectacular sunsets. It is an extremely romantic setting and a perfect place for a special occasion with your significant other. You will go back completely rejuvenated.

They also have a great restaurant on site. The cocktails are great too. I would strongly recommend that you have your own car as this property is away form main Rincon. Rincon is a lovely town and there are also some lovely small towns and beaches nearby. You may want to get out once in a while for a short drive or change of scenery, but most of the time you will be quite happy here.