We had been traveling n Oz quite a bit and staying in hotels was starting to burn our budget. We therefore picked Olembia off the strength of the reviews below.
I feel the balance of the reviews here is exactly right. This place isn't luxury, it isn't glossy and it does feel a bit old and tatty in places but fundamentally that's because it's a hostel and should be judged as such.
The place is clean and tidy, the showers and toilets are good, and the beds seem more than adequate. Our private double room was a quirky split level thing and it served our few nights really well.
The hostel manager was really nice and extremely helpful when I tried to check in outside of the office hours (thank again!) plus there's a car park at the back and wifi inside (which is slow but passable)
The location is spot on if you're planning to spend time in St Kilda and the transport links are good enough if you want to get in and out of the city,
Overall, a very good stay, (and on balance much better than some hotels we've stayed in on our travels!)
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC