What a disappointment. Having been lured in by the promises on the website, our Saturday night stay at The Mill for a surprise birthday celebration for a friend can only be described as a massive let down. On the positive side, the staff on reception and in the bar were great, and did everything they could to ensure our friend did not find out we were at the hotel and luring him into the bar where we were waiting for him. But that was the only good thing about our stay. So what was wrong with this place that so many others have raved about?
1) The bar shuts at 4pm and doesn't open again until the evening. Why, when there are guests wanting to have a drink, does it insist on this and leaves people sitting in near darkness whilst they pull down the shutters and exit the building?
2) The dining room has zero atmosphere - bright lights and big open spaces, over compensated by a (good) pianist playing way too loudly.
3) The food was a disgrace. The Table d'hote menu is £27.50 on a Saturday night - certainly not cheap - and for that I expect a better than decent meal. What we got was overcooked and tasteless. My duck was grey, dry and one slice was so tough I could not cut it. the 'berry sauce' was thin, with no taste other than 'sour'. A friend's pork chop was dry and overcooked, and a vegetarian friend was charged £7.20 for a starter of half a melon with a single ball of sorbet inside it. This was served with a knife and fork to eat it with! Vegetables were generous and consisted of roast and boiled potatoes, green beans dressed with tinned tomatoes, sliced leeks and mushy brocolli.
4) Included in the room rate is only a continental breakfast. This consists of cereal, toast and croissants. If you want a cooked breakfast it's an incredible additional £8.50 - and this is not for a buffet but for a served plate of food. I asked for hot chocolate to drink at breakfast and was told that 'they were out of chocolate'. This is despite the fact that the tray in our room contained a sachet of drinking chocolate.
5) Check in time is 3pm - no problem apart from the fact that check out time is 10am. Does it really take 5 hours to clean the 40 odd rooms? 10am is way too early to have to check out on a Sunday morning.
6) Despite the brochure saying that all rooms look onto the gardens, our room looked on to a carpark! Having said that, the window was so small as to make it immaterial.
7) Our bed was very hard and very lumpy. The duvet was too small for the bed, but the duvet cover was enormous, leaving huge amounts of spare material with no duvet to fill it. Very odd.
8) The room was adequate. The best bit was huge (for a hotel) bath towels.
This place has great potential - it's a fabulous setting - and they say they are going to build a spa. But we could not recommend this to anyone expecting a 4* hotel.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC