We had stayed in other hotels in Pontresina. A last-minute decision for a holiday there limited our options and I went for the available Rosatsch, having noticed its central location on earlier visits. I was also swayed by the fact that it has its own pool and spa, nice after a hard day's skiing or hiking, or if the weather lets you down, but now that Pontresina has a new pool/spa complex, perhaps this is not so important.
The hotel doesn't win points for either modern chic or for old Swiss charm. One portion - the Residenz - appears to be a '70's building, functional, leaning toward traditional in style, and not hideous. I chose the original building, the Stammhaus, which at least seemed to have character. For me, the character was somewhat spoiled by artificial flowers everywhere, including in the swimming area. But the main downside was our bathroom. The first room we were offered was spacious and quite pleasant, but the bathroom was incredibly dark and dated. After a short tour of what was available, we went for an attic room, small but quite charming, and although we noticed that the bathroom was very small, at least it was white and bright. It wasn't until we used it that we realized that the bath was much too small to be comfortable, and the shower had to be held in one hand to direct the spray - a HUGE downer. I don't know if we would have been better off choosing a room with shower only, or looking into the rooms at the Residenz.
The food at the hotel - breakfast and dinner - was EXCELLENT, both in terms of choice and quality. Unusual for a Swiss mountain hotel, fish was an option every day we were there. The salad bar was exceptional, and on occasion the starter or desert courses were buffet, and incredible. I would give the hotel 5 out of 5 for food, but 2 out of 5 for the room.
I had a mixed feeling about the service and general ambiance. The owner was at times very pleasant, the service in the dining room was efficient (but a knowledge of German helped) - the head waiter was especially good, the atmosphere wasn't as international as at other Pontresina hotels. The hotel didn't exactly spill out with help and information. That was okay for me, as we were familiar with the area, but first timers would do well to go to the nearby excellent Tourist Office for information about the area and to explore the hotel's facilities for themselves. Also, we had to remind staff to give us our Engadin Inclusive cards for free transport. There was a little something lacking in the hotel - an eagerness to please, joy, perhaps. Would I return to the hotel? Hmmm. Thinking of the food, yes!! The swimming pool was large, little used, and okay apart from the artificial flowers. There was no garden or terrace - which would have been nice on a summer evening. But thinking of the bathroom and other options available, well ... maybe not. But then perhaps the rooms in the Residenz are better. And the food was really good!!
