Firstly, I have no idea what planet the 5 people are on who think this hotel is terrible, they could not be further from the truth!
We toured Italy in September 2011, we stayed in Venice, Florence, Rome, Seiano and finally Sicily, all the hotel's were 5 star and I thought this hotel was the best.
We were welcomed on arrival (at the front gate!), baggage took to room (with no pressure of tipping), a tour of hotel, offered glass of water and checked in with no issues.
We had the basic room (without the spectacular sea view), so the room was small but immaculate, everything felt brand new and was perfectly quiet at night.
The pool was perfect and easily had enough sun beds.
The breakfast was something else, freshly baked and plenty of cakes and delivered on a balcony with the best view.
As for evening meals, you really need to get down to the village (as the michelin star restaurant is expensive). The Hotel will drive you down to the village in evening, just remember to book your seat.
Really enjoyed this hotel thanks.
Room Tip: If you can afford the sea view it would be VERY worthwhile, stunning view.
See more room tips
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC