I've given this place the benefit of the doubt because my particular experience seems at odds with the general high level of praise from other contributors. In a less generous mood, I'd rate it Good (not Very Good and certainly not Excellent). What is excellent is its location - bang in the centre of Tropea, a lovely, atmospheric little town, full of charm and character and well worth a visit ('though a stay of more then a couple of days would require a rental car to get to the other accessible beaches and few places of interest). The breakfasts at Antica have been well praised - and deservedly so, because the choice is large and varied. But there, for me, the Excellent ends and the Average begins. The rooms, when you peel away some of the gimmicky decor, are basic. I stayed in one of the Suites and while it was exactly as described (simple, cosy) it was also exposed to an open courtyard (as were ALL the suites) which meant that there was almost constant pedestrian traffic and noise of other guests as they made their way to their rooms. To eliminate the noise meant shutting and shuttering your door, and that rendered your room totally dark as there was no other window in the suite. In the courtyard and around the main building, there are some interesting little nooks and crannies with seating for guests. And I'm sure this is great if the weather is dry. But alas, during my stay it rained three or four times. And because nobody ever emerged from the Hotel to save the seat cushions, they became sodden and remained so for the week I was there. In other words, there was no place to sit. Other correspondents were also lavish in their praise for the proprietors. Well, I'd love to agree but not once was I asked whether I was enjoying my stay, or whether I needed directions, or restaurant recommendations or anything. In fact, I passed Reception fourteen times to and from breakfast and not once was I accorded even a basic greeting. None of this negative stuff should, however, deter those who want an up-market Bed and Breakfast (for that's really what it is ) in a smashing location and one, to be fair, is really good value for money.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC