Please do not book this hotel. It is out of the main part of the city, in a terrible neighborhood, and on a busy main intersection of two four-lane roads. We pulled in late at night after driving for nine hours and expected the same treatment as the other hotels we had stayed in all over Europe. The door man said "You want ALL this luggage up to the room?" then he proceeded to start taking the luggage out and put it in the middle of the parking lot. (There is no entry - the front door opens onto the parking lot, which evidently we were not allowed to use.) We asked him if he had a cart for the luggage and he misunderstood and said "Parking garage is across the street (4 busy lanes). You go park it yourself." My husband said "Don't you have valet?" and he responded "yes, but you go park it yourself" so it took my husband 45 minutes to park the car. We got up to the room and it looked like a bordello. Every wall was done in salmon-colored brocade and accented by RED velvet! All the furniture was upholstered in flocked red velvet, and the bed was hard as a rock. The room was old, and garish, and we immediately started looking for another hotel until we realized we would have to pay a day's penalty, and honestly we were so tired we thought that maybe we could get used to it. The worse part was the attitude of about half the staff. I asked a very nice lady at check in if we were in the main part of the city and she said yes (though we weren't) and she said they had a complementary courtesy van for anywhere we wanted to go. So the next day we go down and try to make reservations to the Duomo at 10:00 the next day. The concierge was so rude and acted like we were interrupting his busy day even though there was no one else there. This man continued to treat us like that the entire time, and I wondered how they could have customers with him being so prickly. Then I noticed that whenever the customers were Italian, he was all smiles. There was another concierge who was nice to us, but he was hardly ever there. The bag boys and the wait staff in the restaurant were all huffy toward us as well, though not to the Italians. When we went downstairs to go to the Duomo the next day, we were told that the courtesy car hours had changed so that they didn't start until 10:00. We presented the card we had be given showing that the courtesy car was supposed to start at 9:30 and said "the concierge just made us an appointment yesterday and we have to be there at 10:00." He just shrugged and said the times had changed, they would call us a taxi. So while we were waiting for the taxi, the courtesy car driver shows up (at 9:30) and so we ask him if he will take us anyway, and he says well he will have to check to see if someone else (probably Italian) would need the car at 10:00. He went inside, then came out smiling and whistling, locked the van door and walked off without saying a word to us.
The rooms were old and hot and didn't have air conditioning. Though we had a balcony that overlooked a beautiful courtyard, it was so noisy out there from the traffic I couldn't even read out there. The hotel is in a terrible part of town. The first two nights we left the windows open to cool off the room and there were drunks yelling until 4:00 am, dogs barking, sirens going off every hour, and cars going by and honking. We walked back from a restaurant one night and were in fear for our lives with the hoodlums on the streets. Oh yes, the restaurants don't open until 7:30 at night and the hotel changed the courtesy car hours the day after we got there so they stopped at 8:00.
We started looking online, and the Villa Medici shows only the common areas that look modern, which is quite misleading. When we started looking further, we found that the Villa Medici is not even rated in the top 100 hotels in Florence -142nd to be exact. The rudeness and snotty attitudes by about half the staff just wore us down day after day, and it kind of put a pall on the whole trip for us. Kind of a bummer especially since we were paying over $400 a night.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC