I've just returned from a 3 night stay at La Dimora di Genio, a solus photographic trip. I'd booked in here before reading the mixed reports on Tripadvisor, so was unsure what to expect. Here's my own view.
Location - is in the old part of the city (not necessarily the poorest, as another report suggests). Whether or not it's the best location depends on why you're visiting Palermo - if it's to experience the city 'for real' then here is a good place to base yourself. Just 5 minutes walk from the railway station, easy access to all major sights including the markets of Vucciria, Capo and Ballaro. Agree it's not that easy to find, but Via Garibaldi isn't that long a street, so it's not impossible either.
The owner - Paola Mendola's English isn't strong (but then neither is my Italian!) But with a little effort and goodwill we communicated. The housekeeper speaks a little more English and I found both very helpful. Signora Mendola provided restaurant recommendations and directions.
The accommodation - inside, the house is elegant and beautifully furnished, with a lived-in quality that makes it a pleasant place to return to after exploring the city. You're given the keys to the building, the house and your room, so you're left pretty much to your own devices and to come and go as you please. My room was spacious with 3 single beds and a writing desk, and a large ensuite bathroom with toilet, bidet, washbasin and shower. Everything was spotlessly clean. Note that, in my room at any rate, there was no wardrobe or drawers, just a hanging rail in the bathroom. (This was fine for me, but I know my wife wouldn't have been impressed!) Also there are no fridges or tea/coffee-making facilities in the rooms. Breakfast was pleasant and varied a little each morning, and shared with other guests.
The noise - if you are easily disturbed or annoyed by extraneous noise, this probably isn't the place for you! When I was there a lot of building work was going on around La Dimora, and from about 7.30am to 6.00pm this was evident in hammer blows, chisel taps, drilling and the singing and whistling of workmen. (Though I was out for most of the days, I was in my room when it started and again when it finished, so presume it continued throughout the day - with a break for lunch!) A French window in my room overlooked the alleyway below, where a family played out daily life with children playing and shouting, much loud conversation and laughter and, of course, the frequent buzzing of scooters. Not only didn't I mind this, but it added to my enjoyment and experience of the city, but I can understand that, at 10 or 11 in the evening, not everyone would think so!
So, my advice...
DON"T GO HERE if you like hotel comforts, have no will to try and speak a few words of Italian, or no sense of direction. And especially if you are sensitive to noise.
DO GO HERE if you want to immerse yourself in a slice of Palermitan life for a few days, with all that entails, in beautiful old house in a convenient location. I thoroughly enjoyed my stay here.
