I spent one night in this hotel prior to a meeting in Girona (and a trip home via the Trenhotel, which I thoroughly recommend, but can't easily review here.) I wasn't looking for much; a drink when I arrived, working internet, a decent night's sleep, breakfast and a quick checkout. I got some of those.
So, good points first. The rooms are decent, comfortable and well-provided. There's an abundance of freebies in the bathroom and you get a bathrobe and slippers, unusual now in all but the priciest hotels. It's well-located in a quiet side-street very close to the tourist sights and only 10 minutes walk from the train and bus station. They have wifi, but it needs a password and it wasn't offered to me - I had to request it. Although the lobby has a sign proclaiming it to be the wifi zone, I never got it to work there but did succeed in my room later.
The lobby also had a bar. But this didn't actually seem to be available for use, although staff from the hotel restaurant were popping in and out of the bar all night. I asked when I arrived if I could get a drink and was told that I couldn't do that unless I ate in the restaurant. There wasn't really any explanation or apology for this, despite the fact that the bar is clearly separate. The restaurant itself looked excellent and good value, but I had eaten on my (long) journey there, and I just wanted a drink. I was told to find a bar somewhere else.
Breakfast was reasonable continental; not great, not bad. It wasn't at all clear when I booked that it wasn't included (in fact, 'everything included' looks a lot like the opposite to me - but so it goes.)
The second failure with service occurred when I wanted a taxi. It was ordered promptly & without fuss, and the failure of the taxi company to show up was not the hotel's fault. But after I had been waiting nearly 30 minutes, and had asked more than once what was happening, they should have tried something else - another number, something like that. I eventually abandoned them, walked down the street and found 10 cabs waiting on a rank 5 minutes away. (That problem wasn't unique to this hotel, as a colleague had a similar problem at another hotel in Girona that day.)
So I'm ambivalent about a recommendation. The room I was in would not be comfortable for more than a day or three - not enough space to be more than a business hotel, or somewhere just to sleep. If you need a base and no more, this could be good - there's lots of places to eat and drink nearby.