We stayed here along with my parents on December 4. The location, first of all, was perfect as far as I'm concerned. There was a parking lot behind the building. Breakfast and check-in were across the street. It's on Untere Schmiedgasse, which may be the most picturesque part of Rothenburg.

They were a little short-staffed when we were there. On the one hand when we came to the desk they were extremely helpful. The guy I talked to about breakfast was eager to tell us about the town and give recommendations. On the other hand, we could feel how the place was short-staffed at the time when it came to breakfast. The breakfast was excellent but the hot water dispenser was empty (so no tea), the juice dispensers were almost empty as well, and it was hard to find anyone to help us with it. This was at 0730-0800. Those were minor things and not worth dinging the hotel in rating.

The rooms were comfortable (except the toilet in our particular room was unfortunately squeezed between the tub and the wall), and the shower leaked and had no curtain or barrier. However shutting the bathroom door completely blocked the noise. The rooms smelled and looked like they'd been recently refurbished.

Overall worth the price. Our only complaints were the shortage of staff at breakfast and the leaky shower, but we paid 119 Euro (initially booked a family room for four but when we got there they just gave us two rooms). The location, value, and good breakfast more than made up for the minor annoyances.

This is a very pleasant hotel. Its members are kind and warmly polite. Well situated, its accommodations are simply but comfortable. The breakfast is very good.

We stayed in the Pension of Goldener Hirsch (the gold deer) on the opposite of the street of the hotel. The parking was next to the pension and breakfast was in the hotel. Eventhough it was not very busy at the moment we stayed the night, service was ok. As most of the things in Rothenburg, the pension was a bit dated as well, but nothing was broken and everything was clean & working. Just the thing you expect in a pension in Germany. The town is quite funny, they still give you the atmosphere of going back centuries in time. (shops where you can buy swords & teddy bears, local delicacies and guided tours through the small town with a knight)
We stayed at Rothenburg for the night on our way back home from Italy and it was nice as it still gave us the holiday feeling. Eventhough it's only 3 km from the German Autobahn.

I loved this town. The hotel had an lovely olden day feel to it, there was a massive room with a piano, a bar was connected to it. The room was spacious, clean and had a lovely view of the valley. It is centrally located in the old town. The reception staff were lovely, breakfast was good and there was off street parking. I would definitely stay here again.