This is an excellent hotel in Saint Tropez: excellent location, excellent service, excellent restaurant. The 4 stars are totally fair and correct.
In Saint Tropez you have three or four 5-star hotels (Byblos is one of them) and six or seven 4 star-hotels. If you are looking for a 4 star-hotel, cosy, romantic, quiet and charming "La Ponche" is a fantastic solution.
The hotel is located in Rue des Pecheurs/Rue des Remparts, a 3 minutes walking from the marine and from the center of the village. There is a car parking (21 euro/day).
The staff is very helpful and the room is extremely clean. The staff cleans the room twice a day: in the morning when you go to the beach and in the evening when we go out to dinner.
The restaurant is certainly one of the best in Saint Tropez and with a fantastic sea view (La Ponche Bay). The breakfast has everything you need: milk, coffee, tea, croisssants, bagguette, butter, pain aux chocolat, orange/peach/framboise/strawberry jam, yogurt, honey. It is not included in the price. We had breakfast at the hotel (19 euro each) rather than have breakfast at the marine full of tourists ("Senequier" at the marine, for instance, takes a lot of time to be served).
We stayed at Room 14, which we recommend. It is a large room, with a small balcony with a sea view. Large and very clean WC.
This is a historical hotel (it has a book published about it). Picasso, actress Romy Schneider, the former French President George Pompidou and others have stayed here, and the rooms have their names (Picasso Room, Pompidou Room, etc.).
After staying in Saint Tropez for the first time, there is no doubt that if we go back there we will stay at "La Ponche" and recomend it to our relatives and friends.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC