The last thing I expected to occur when booking into this hostel was to be asaulted, let alone by the manager, as a consequence of ringing the bell to get inside @2AM because the front door, knowingly to owner and staff, is a bit dicky and can be difficult to open. The manager, had had a few and in a state, decided I wasn't allowed in and threw me down the stairs.
I eventually got in and saw him the next day, but rather than apologise or even discuss his actions I was threatened with further physical abuse and thrown out.
Absolutely inexplicable behaviour, especially for someone involved in the hospitality industry.
Ruined my time in Inverness not only due to the obvious bad experience but by completely debilitating my right leg (my knee has blown up like a watermelon!)
Shockingly, the owner, and also owner of Cowgate Tourist Hostel in Edinburgh, witnessed me getting threatened and told to leave by the manager, yet seemed to show no particular interest in what was going on - a common occurrence?
Highly unsatisfactory experience.
Room Tip: Go To A Different Hostel
See more room tips
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
8 December 2011
Hello Dan F
Very disappointed you decided to write this review and I note you wrote it the day after when emotions were still high. After getting no ‘satisfaction’ from the staff, myself the manager, the owner or the police (which I note you haven’t mentioned) you took the route to attack the hostel and my reputation through a Tripadvisior ‘review’.
I don’t want to respond but I have too as what you say can be very damaging if I don’t. Also, it has a serious lack of detail about your behaviour that night and morning that I need to make people reading aware.
First off I’ll define the ‘assault’ and unprovoked physical abuse you describe, which was me escorting you down two flights of stairs after you repeatedly refused to leave the hostel after been asked to ‘walk it off’ i.e. come back when you were sober
Secondly, can you advise on why you fail to mention you calling the police and their zero response after seeing the evidence on CCTV?
Thirdly, can you on advise why you have you’ve not mentioned threating a young female member of staff the following morning for your money back? It would explain why the owner and I were not too interested in taking you seriously in the morning. Could this lack of interest explain your attack on the owner as well?
And no, what happened is not a common occurrence and the first time I have encountered anything like this in 12 years in hospitality.
As you were very intoxicated that night I will retort too help you recall and to let people reading make up their own mind on the hostel and my reputation and name which you so frivolously attack;
Leaving your finger on the door buzzer for 47 seconds to wake staff (I counted as you were on CCTV, and it was after 3am as well) because you were so drunk you couldn’t open the door, is a total disregard for us and more importantly the other guests staying at the hostel trying to sleep. Why you were surprised that I wasn’t too happy when I came down the stairs says a lot about just how intoxicated and confused you were that night. You then kept insisting the door wasn’t working, and as you were another guest arrived back and opened it no problem. Do you recall this? You had a chat with him and tried to get him involved in your argument. Yes the door gets a bit ‘dicky’ when it rains, as you know because we explained this to you when you checked in, and all you needed to do is push the door then pull it open. I asked you to leave as you kept up the argument that the door wasn’t working and you were getting more and more aggressive and beginning to alarm other guests who were still awake. I repeatedly asked you to leave and to walk it off.
You followed me up the stairs continuing your argument and at this point I decided you needed help leaving and escorted you down the stairs.
The following morning you came back and had the audacity to threaten a young member of staff for your money back. You were asked to leave again, not threatened, and you agreed. Eventually you did but only after making yourself some free coffee from our kitchen!
We do a brilliant job around here and our reviews from September on all the major booking websites confirm this and it’s a real shame people can sign up to a website and try and get some revenge for some injustice they recall from a very drunken state.
Regardless, I wish you all the best and hope you enjoy the rest of your travels.
Report response as inappropriate
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of TripAdvisor LLC