I stayed at Manukan Island Resort in a two bedroom, single story cottage, with three other friends for two nights in January. The whole experience was excellent and exactly what we hoped for.
The rate included round trip transfer via the Sea Quest tour company but the day we were meant to travel, it was on and off torrential rain all day. We had to wait at the jetty for a bit until it was safe to travel, we ended up traveling in the rain anyway, which was an adventure in itself! The staff was very pleasant on check in and we were thrilled with the accomodation. The room was very cute, and while slightly dated and run down, added charm to the island experience. Admittedly, linens and towels were noticably old and could stand to be replaced, but as those things don't bother me, I wasn't particularly fussed.
The island, as we came to figure out, is flooded by day with tour groups, but very quiet at night. Even though there were hundreds of day trippers, we were able to spend the day down the beach and enjoy a bit of quiet. There are some things reserved for resort guests only (beach chairs and umbrellas, use of the pool), which was appreciated. The last of the ferries leaves the island by about 4pm so the rest of the day is very peaceful. While we were there, only 3 or 4 of the cottages were occupied so we felt like we had the resort to ourselves.
There is a nice hike to sunset point which we really enjoyed. The total walk is 1500 meters and at the end, there is a small path down to the rocky coast and provides beautiful views of the South China Sea.
The food is typical resort food, and while not fantastic, there is an assortment of options from traditional Asian to classic Western, and thought the prices were reasonable as well. Worth noting the service is quite slow, but since we had no where to be, it didn't matter too much. I can imagine it must be even slower when the resort is fully booked.
Overall, we LOVED the experience but must point out that it is not a 5 star luxury resort (and is significantly less expensive than the accomodations available on Gaya Island). While everything was fantastic and we loved the trip, there is a rustic feel which at times made us feel like we were on a deserted island.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC