We spent two nights there, two weeks apart, on both ends of a trip South.
We only booked this hotel when the Sandman was full. I guess that's what you get for writing a positive review :) Caution: there is another Best Western, which also calls itself Best Western Plus Airport, on Dixie Rd. This review is about the one on Eglinton Avenue. But this hotel won us over and we now have a choice of two hotels with restaurant, which is very useful in this thruway desert zone around Pearson airport, but if you get there after 10 p.m., it's pizza only, delivery only. Nothing else for miles.
The room was smaller than most (your roommate will have to make you move if you are working at the desk and (s)he wants to get to the other chair or the window), furnished in the requisite dark wood and silver accents. There is a work-size desk (the free wifi worked beautifully), two excellent beds, a bigger than average fridge with good-size freezer compartment (we take frozen food on our trips to the islands, with mixed result at security: some agents will let it go if it is frozen solid) and good size flat=screen TV. On the other hand, drawer space is dismal (three small one next to the fridge), and the clothes closet is adequate, not one inch more. Bathroom is fine, and it was spotless.
Sleep quality in the rooms at the 'back' (overlooking the parking lot and golf course) is excellent.
The shuttle service, on time and exact, is outstanding (6mn., 10 in rush hour traffic). The staff also deserve great praise, from the desk clerks to the shuttle drivers: friendly, efficient and helpful, they know that at airports promptness is paramount.
The attached restaurant (MIckele's, note the k, probably to ensure the Italian pronunciation) is very good (see separate review), and serves as the locale for the complimentary so-so breakfast (no hot items in the buffet).
Our bill for one night, dinner for two with wine was under $190 all included (taxes and tip), which has to be excellent value. And they cheerfully kept a bag of our winter stuff, no charge, for the two weeks (and retrieved it immediately on request).
All in all, an excellent experience, and an address to keep in mind when traveling through Pearson.

We stayed here January 12, 2012 before flying to Cozumel for a week. The rooms were clean and nicely decorated and the beds were very comfortable. Bathrooms were a bit plain, but still functional. The shuttle to the airport at 4:30 in the morning was great - the driver was wonderful. Very social and courteous. A great place to stay and before flying out of Pearson.

I have stayed at this hotel many a time. the staff is friendly and professional. The recently renovated rooms are just beautiful. Shuttle service to the Pearson Airport is safe and courteous...and they have a new van now.
I prefer not to eat the complimentary breakfast (not a fan) but there is a Country Style just beside the hotel. There is also a Tim Horton's two blocks down the road.

I stayed at this hotel with my family before leaving on vacation in December 2011. The location is easy to get to, South of the 401, and about 5 minutes from the airport. There is not much within walking distance for restaurants, but there is an Italian restaurant onsite, which doubles as the free breakfast area in the morning. The room was clean and quiet, with comfortable beds and 12ft ceilings (ground floor). The breakfast is pretty much a standard continental breakfast: (toast, cereal, fruit, oatmeal, waffles and tea/coffee/juice.) All the staff are very friendly, and we had excellent and efficient shuttle van service to and from the airport. It was very nice having the shuttle van arrive for pickup upon our return in less than 10 minutes. (Unlike many other airport hotels I've experienced, waiting 20 minutes or more.) I would recommend this hotel all around, but especially if you are looking for one close to the airport with reasonable park and fly rates and free airport shuttle service.