The algonquin seemed to me to be a work in progress.... The staff(frank,chris and DJ) were very helpful and friendly.Chris went out of his way to help me to interpret my map.It is an old,stately building that must have an interesting history.The owner would do well in putting up old pictures and a short historical explanation of this hotel as i am sure it would interest travellers... They have an excellent set-up for entertainement! A pub like atmosphere with live bands and an outside deck attached to it which is sure to please young travellers. The lobby is nice and appears to be recently renovated. I slept in room # 5 and #15 on 2 separate occasions during the same week. Room # 5 was comfortable,the only complaint being that it was very hot due to poor ventilation in the room. Room #15 was absolutly disgusting as it smelled of mold,mildew or some dead animal... i,m not quite sure! I suspect it was due either to the carpet or ''dry rot''. The owner would do well in removing the carpet and putting ceramic tiling in the bathroom to offset this.I do hope that she responds to this comment as it will show wether or not she is serious about completing the transformation of this building into a user friendly environnement for hostellers... A good paint job wouldn't hurt either as room colors are a dingy off-white yellowish color... yuk! Room 15 is also just above the live band stage which makes it noisy but hey,it's billed as a youth hostel, right? Bed linen appeared clean to me,but that smell would be enough to convince just about anybody otherwise... Carpeting in the stairs leading to the rooms could also be removed,in my opinion as i am sure that there are beautiful wood stairs under there that would bring out the character and stately charm of the building. I would also put in a common kitchen/room eventually so hostellers could cook their own meals and swap travel stories as the pub is not open every day of the week. Bottom line is that hostels usually provide comparitively cheap,simple,clean and confortable accomodation.The algonquin is not presently fulfilling this mission. I would not want my 20 yr old daughter spending in one of those rooms...
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC