My rating is actually "Good", not "Average", rating it compared with other Yellowknife hotels I have used. This is definitely the best, but there is room for improvement.
On the plus side, the rooms are nice, good decor. Staff are friendly, and I found the hotel bar/restaurant very good. Free Wifi is always a plus, especially since my blackberry did not work in town, just in the hotel. I also found myself in need of a dentist, and there is one right next to the hotel, a very nice dental practice that fixed me up with a smile. The fact that they have smoking rooms is also a bonus, as I prefer not to have to go out in the cold and wind for a puff. There is also a coffee maker in the room. The rooms were clean, but I have seen better. The bed was hard but fairly comfortable.
On the downside, there is a rather treacherous walk from the hotel into town. with ice and snow on the steep sidewalk in front of the hotel, I was forced to walk on the steep driveway, which is not a good thing. For my entire stay (3 days) nothing appeared to have been done about that sidewalk. Also, it would have been great to have a mini-fridge in the room to hold the milk that I bought for my coffee. I kept it on ice in the ice bucket. As it is, there is only one ice machine in the hotel and that is in the lobby, so it's a bit of an ordeal to keep anything cold in the room.
It would also be a nice touch to have a cordless phone in the room, for versatility. Staff were OK but resistant to my request for a late check-out (one hour). When I persisted (explaining that my plane would not leave for another two hours), they acquiesced, but didn't ask for my room number or make any calls. So why the resistance if it was simply a matter of saying "yes"? All that being said, I would stay there again, because it is better than the others. Nevertheless, they need to go farther to be better than the equivalent to a 3 star in more southerly cities, i.e. Edmonton or Winnipeg.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC