My husband and I stayed here over a long weekend to snorkel, dive, and see a little more of the island than we'd seen on previous trips. For the price we paid (about $60 with breakfast) it was a good value.
The room we stayed in was a large palapa with a king-size bed, private bathroom with shower, and lots of amenities: A/C, ceiling fan, kitchen area with fridge, sink and microwave, a hammock, safe deposit box, reading selection, etc. The bed was very firm because it was just a mattress on top of a concrete slab. Also, the room let a lot of light in, so it was difficult to sleep past sunrise (about 6:30am). The shower had lots of pressure and hot water. No bath amenities were provided so bring your own shampoo, conditioner, and soap.
The breakfasts were just OK. Coffee and orange juice, small fruit plate, then the breakfast of the day which varied from eggs to two slices of french toast to three small quesadillas. It was decent, but there was definitely room to improve on the quality and presentation.
The owner Jorge was the best part of Amaranto. He was very helpful and friendly, and always around to answer questions. He was generous with bath towels and toilet paper, and helped us set up a rental car, which came and picked us up right at the B&B. He also pointed us towards a dive shop that rented us a wetsuit for $5 and then let us leave the wetsuit at the B&B, which was really convenient for us.
Like any hotel or B&B, it's all about your expectations. If you are expecting a five-star quality place then you will be disappointed. But if you want somewhere clean, affordable and comfortable then Amaranto fits the bill.
