I stayed here 9 years ago and the only major difference was that the gardens have grown alot. This is not a fancy property. The rooms are big but the mattress and pillows left a lot to be desired. Maid service consisted mainly of making the bed. There was sand in the shower for three days before she cleaned it. I can only describe the breakfast as bad; weak coffee, dry muffins and terrible generic Mexican cereal. On the positive side; it was quiet and peaceful. There is a hammock in front of each room, the AC was great and a large pool. The location is extremely convenient to the downtown restaurants. If you are on a budget this is a good choice. If you are looking for luxury you might want to consider somewhere else.

The garden here is simple and relaxing. The pool is great and well maintained. The staff cleaned room each day. The room is simple, but it works, and it was nice to have fridge in room. The room AC was great, and was such a relief from the Cozumel sun. Breakfast was a treat, as I was introduced to some fruits I had never heard of, right from the garden. Have you eaten Guanabana? The most God-awful looking thing with spines on a brown skin, the size of a football. Inside, white pulpy meat that is sweet. The common area is outdoors, and can be hot, but I suspect that most folks are going to be out and about, diving tours, at the beach and whatnot, so for most folks this wouldn't be a problem. We enjoyed the other guests.
This place in a neighborhood, and most Gringo visitors don't realize that Cozumel actually has neighborhoods. I think that Amigos is a great value, and added to out trip.

The grounds are beautiful!! Very nice pool. Very good continental plus breakfast. Easy walking distance to downtown and many local restaurants and grocery stores. The common palapa was great and the wifi worked well. The maid cleaned every day and did an excellent job. Nice little kitchen in room. Rooms very comfortable with A/C. Lots of good info about the island provided. Kathy was very helpful in getting our car rental straightened out.
Had the place to ourselves the first 2 days then another couple came.

If you find comfort and satisfaction in being on a schedule and following rules, this is definitely the place for you. However, for those merely seeking relaxation and not interested in following petty rules from an autocratic "host," you would be well advised to steer clear. Unless, that is, you have a taste for the ridiculous or the absurd in which case you are likely to find much entertainment in the long, trifling reprimands you can expect Kathy to be sliding under your door.

If you do decide to go, you may wish to note that while coffee is available for purchase, it may only be brewed in the afternoon or evenings and use of the milk or sweetener is strictly prohibited. For the recalcitrant who dare brew their coffee in the morning, expect to have it confiscated.