Apparently new owners are working to refit a quirky property. Obviously converted from some other previous life.
Fully acceptable for younger guests; but, not terribly mobility friendly. Staff was very pleasant. Window air conditioners very noisy. Impressed by quality of replacement fixtures and workmanship.
Staff did not offer compensation when they were informed of rainwater dripping from ceiling onto bed.
Adorable dog on premesis.

We stayed at the St John Inn over the Thanksgiving Holiday and we are "Thankful" for the St John Inn. What a wonderful find! The room was very quaint, the property well maintained, and the staff was just awesome. Our room was clean and very comfortable - we had everything we needed during our 4 night stay. The location was not only close enough to town to take a nice walk every morning but it provided a nice evening stroll for dinner. Additionally, there are two car rental services across the street which make it easy to pick up a jeep to run to the other side of the island. Every morning, the continental breakfast, towels, and beach chairs were waiting for our enjoyment. No review of the St. John Inn would be complete without mentioning Killer, the resident love puppy, I mean guard dog. Killer greeted us every morning and every evening when we returned from dinner - he filled in admirably for the two dogs we left behind and were missing. We visit St John several times a year and I have seen the St. John Inn advertised as a budget accommocation in the past but we never tried it becuase sometines "budget" means dump. This is far from the case at St John Inn, we actually found it more of a boutique option for the island and we highly recommend the Inn! Only one suggestion for the team at STJ Inn - the evening rum punch isnt a traditional rum punch, happy hour would be much more succedssful with a new recipe...

We stayed in St. John while visiting our daughter and she got us to stay at the St. John Inn. It is right in town, easy walk into the shops, bars, ferry dock, etc. The room was clean and came with coffee pot and microwave. We went to the beach and they had coolers and beach chairs that we could borrow which was an added bonus. We never took advantage of the pool but it was nice to know that it was there. The breakfast and happy hour were nice touches as well. Overall, I will always be staying here when we visit our daughter. The staff was nice and helped us with any questions we had!

St John inn was an experiment in inexpensive hotels on St John. It was well worth the effort. The place is obviously a restoration "project". The hotel is well cared for by the staff and well restored. The most important aspects of the hotel are its cleanliness, character and an obvious effort on the part of the staff (this includes "lady Killer" the dog) to make the experience enjoyable and quietly pleasant. Liza the manager, makes every effort to make you feel welcome,as you were staying in her own home. For the price, you will not beat it on this island.