I have owned timeshares in both Aruba and Harborside and Atlantis. My friend and I arrived and were greeted with our first jumbo jetliner taking off, which to be honest you get used to. What took us back was the horrific mildew smell the minute the room to our villa was opened. The resort old and so are all the appliances and bathrooms. We couldn't use the dishwasher because it is so old the writing is worn off, so you just end up puching bunch of buttons to see if you can get it on. The kitchen cabinets had hardware missing and were falling apart. The kitchen sink was the size of one you might see in an RV. There was mold in not only the bathroom, but also in the kitchen on the ceiling! We had a two bedroom, but could not use the second one because the shower leaked and the tub was so high you could barely get in and out. The air conditioning unit is ancient. Its a big piece of machinery attached to the ceiling and could only be turned to med and hign, no temp, so we had to keep turning it on and off. The front door faced the street, most do, so you get all the traffic noise, including alarms that go on for hours. The pool was moldy in areas, there are no real activities around the pool, no music. No one to come around so you can order drinks or food. The only restaurant near the pool is cash only because they are not part of the resort. The staff is not accomodating at all. As for the island, I saw nothing pretty, just rundown, beat up buildings, graffiti, lots of traffic on potholed fill roads. We were told by many not to walk the streets at night alone, do not stop for anyone on the street if you are driving. There was alot of security around, so that should have been our first warning. The resort does not have parking, so you have to park in and underground garage across the street and pay for it. The only nice thing about the resort was the pool area, and thats because there was a hurricane last year and they had to re landscape. Other than that, nothing is updated, everything is old and beat up. Its off season, so alot of Maho Beach is closed, so all you have to do at night is watch tv, but wait, they were having trouble with the sattelite, so we lost most channels. I would never return to St. Maarteen and would never recommend the Royal Islander. It is more a time share motel.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC