Just spent a week + at Sanctuary and had a fantastic time. The property is exquisite. There were hardly two dozen guests altogether, so while I can't comment on what the place is like when it's fully booked, I can say that it felt exceptionally private, quiet, and luxurious. Sanctuary was a perfect place to decompress. The property is beautiful, with lush landscaping and several great pools -- all painstakingly maintained. It was a great getaway.
Many thanks to the folks at Jetsetter.com, who helped move my reservation over to Sanctuary after I booked the neighboring property, Fishing Lodge Cap Cana, in a flash sale. As many reviewers have pointed out previously, FL is not ready for prime time -- it's basically a construction site with a gorgeous pool.
I cannot emphasize enough just how friendly and professional the staff at Sanctuary is. From the waiters to the spa attendants to the poolside "entertainment team" to the concierge to each and every individual puttering around the place on a golf cart, staffing the little market, or working in the garden, everyone was incredibly friendly and accommodating. Perhaps a little too doting at times, but in kind of a cute way.
My only complaints:
1) I may be a food snob so take this with a grain of salt, but the food is just ok. Breakfast was always wonderful with a huge display of fresh local fruit and ready-made omelettes etc. There were always 2 choices for lunch and dinner, rotating among the restaurants on the property. The asian place, Wok, was pretty bad. The seafood place, Blue Marlin, was mediocre on a first visit, and I had much better meals once I figured out what to order (the paella, for example, is quite good). The steakhouse is probably the best. I heard complaints about a bad ribeye steak, but I enjoyed the chicken, the pork chops (chuletas), and the skirt steak (churrasco). Poolside grouper sandwiches and burgers were pretty darn good and always hit the spot, but room service was a little hit or miss. One half-eaten vegetarian wrap, left outside for pickup, was enjoyed by the resort's resident cat.
2) Sanctuary has clearly not quite figured out how to handle guests who are not on the all-inclusive plan. I heard all-inclusive guests complaining about filling out receipts for positively everything (and every receipt includes a line for a tip). After reading other reviews, I arrived with a pile of one dollar bills figuring I'd need to tip in cash, so I didn't really mind adding a buck or two to everything purchased -- but some people clearly didn't appreciate this and didn't know what was expected or appropriate (especially since a marginal service charge is already added).
I'm honestly not sure whether paying a la carte for everything was a good value, and on a couple occasions it was awkward -- for example, when the poolside bartender billed me for a bunch of drinks, figuring I was on the all-inclusive plan, and I had a tough time explaining that I wasn't comfortable actually paying cash for a round of drinks for a huge group at the pool. I also had to contest a whole bunch of inexplicable charges for a dozen or more minibar beers I never touched, room service meals I never ordered, etc. Luckily, with some repeated prodding, the staff at the front desk looked into it and I wasn't charged -- but it did kind of make me anxious and made me start hanging on to receipts for everything, which was a drag.
3) I misunderstood from previous reviews the nature of the souvenir sales on the property -- I thought commenters meant that individual salespeople were allowed on the property to hawk their wares, like you might expect to see someone selling roses in a restaurant. In fact, there were several tables set up poolside in a kind of twice weekly, sanctioned "bazaar" sort of atmosphere. The salespeople were extremely pushy -- one actually grabbed my arm -- and they were selling jewelry, liquor, and random souvenirs at a pretty steep markup compared to what I saw in the airport. I walked away and avoided these guys ... but just generally, I would caution visitors that it's hard to get away once you give them the time of day.
4) Finally, I would warn cigar smokers (or would-be gift givers) that the on-premises tobacconist in the market square a few steps from the main lobby sells counterfeit Cubans. I bought and smoked a few, and they didn't taste quite right, so I went online and checked out the labels, which were obvious fakes. I confronted the salesperson (a bit sheepishly, I'll admit) and didn't make a scene or ask for my money back or anything -- but I did ask whether he had any real Cubans for sale amidst the rather impressive collection of Cohibas, Romeo y Julietas, Cuabas, Partagas, etc in the humidor. He shook his head no.
... Hope this review is helpful to prospective Cap Cana-bound travelers. Feel free to message me if you have any specific questions!
Room Tip: Reception offered us a $200/night upgrade to the Honeymoon Suite but we stuck with our original room...
See more room tips
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC