The Stonedge cabins are located on an amazing cliff overlooking the Caribbean Sea. The amenities are basic but adequate, about what you would expect for the price. Didier, the owner, is a friendly guy who is willing to give advice on where to go and how to get there. Dinah, his girlfriend (?) seems genuinely nice. If you are on an extremely limited budget, Stonedge is an option you probably shouldn't overlook. That is the good, here is the bad.
First, the tours...
We chose to stay at Stonedge to take advantage of the cheap tours offered by the owner, Didier. We inquired ahead of time to insure that guided tours would be available during our stay. However, every morning but one we were informed that there would be no tours that day. The one morning when there was a tour we were told that it was going to the north end of the island. Since we were staying in the north for the last days of our trip, we decided not to go. We found out later that Didier changed his mind, without telling us, and took the group to see waterfalls on the southern side of the islands. Other reviews indicate that Didier provides a free tour on Tuesdays -- this appears to no longer be the case.
Second, the mosquitoes...
There are no mosquito nets provided at Stonedge and the cottages get hot hot hot at night. Unless you want to broil, you keep the windows open at night. As a result, our nights were spent hiding under a sheet, listening to the mosquitoes buzzing around our heads. When and if we finally managed to fall asleep, we woke up with itchy bites all over legs, face, arms, ect. After requesting a mosquito net, we were offered bug spray. I was, however, reluctant to spray Deet over my face before sleep -- more bites.
Third, the food...
Dinners cost start at $10 and go up from there. For this price you can get a salad consisting of mostly cabbage or "spaghetti" a.k.a. ramen instant noodles. It's not that the food is really bad (though it's not good) but it's a lot to pay for instant noodles. Breakfasts were a better deal.
Fourth, the location...
Driving ourselves around the island, we found that Salisbury is pretty far from virtually anything on the island you'd want to see. Trafalgar Valley (Boiling Lake hike, Titou Gorge, Trafalgar falls, Middleham falls, ect.) is a 45-60 minute drive, Victoria falls, Champagne Beach, Scotts Head are even further. If you make this your home base on vacation, plan on spending at least 2 hours a day getting to and from where you want to go.
Fourth the company...
Meeting fellow travelers has been one of the highlights of traveling in my experience, and I wish I spoke more languages to broaden the number of travelers I could communicate with. However, I am not fluent in French and I found this to be pretty socially isolating at Stonedge. During our stay, all but one of the other guests spoke almost exclusively in French and the owner concentrated virtually all of his time and attention on those guests. As a result, my boyfriend and I often found ourselves alone at a small table while the rest of the guests socialized a few feet away. I don't really blame the owners for this -- though they could have made some effort to include us -- but it was a bummer. If you are primarily an English speaker, this is something you may want to keep in mind. The island is primarily English speaking and you'll probably be able to meet more people at other guest houses.