This was our third time at the BDI. Had previously travelled there with oldest daughter three years ago. Brought all the kids this time.
The place still maintains it's charm. It has very basic accomodations, but they are spotlessly clean. The place sits right on the water, just north of Small Wall. Small Wall is an excellent site, so much so that dive boats were seen there every day. But, from Black Durgon, it's the "house reef" and is great.
Al is a great guy, and is very patient if you have someone needed some scuba skills work or updates.
The layout of the property is U-shaped, with the dive locker on one side, the open air kitchen on the other, and rooms on the hill, in-between. It is a very quiet and peacefull place, with no rifraff running around. Some of our friends stayed on the south end of the island and had stuff stolen off their balcony. The BDI is about 3 miles north of downtown, and is very, very quiet. There is a convenience store about a mile down the road.
The place has an open-air kitchen, which you are allowed to use. There is a BBQ grill, too. We generally ate out at dinner, but did grill a couple of times.
It is a very relaxing place, and most of the people you meet there are repeat customers (including me). If you're a serious diver, this is a great spot. Tanks are always available, and Al is a wealth of information, and an all-around good guy. For non-divers, the onsite pier has great snorkeling and swimming.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC